Blog
How Atlanta outgrew Savannah by 1880
The census numbers from 1860 to 1890, the railroads behind them and the argument of the New South promoters, with the growth rates worked out.
In 1860 Savannah was more than twice the size of Atlanta. By the census of 1880 the order had flipped. The town Sherman's army burned sixteen years earlier had passed the old colonial port, and it never handed the lead back. Atlantans love to tell this one as a miracle of will, the phoenix and the ashes. The census and the railroad map tell a plainer story, and a more useful one. Atlanta did not win on luck. It won because it sat at the right spot on a new kind of map.
The numbers
The decennial census gives the clearest version.
| Year | Atlanta | Savannah |
|---|---|---|
| 1860 | 9,554 | 22,292 |
| 1870 | about 21,800 | 28,235 |
| 1880 | 37,409 | 30,709 |
| 1890 | about 65,500 | 43,189 |
Two things stand out. Atlanta passed Savannah between 1870 and 1880, not any earlier, and after that the gap only widened. And Savannah did not shrink. It grew in every one of those decades. It lost its place because Atlanta grew faster.
A worked comparison. From 1860 to 1880, Atlanta's population multiplied by about 3.9 (37,409 divided by 9,554). Savannah's multiplied by about 1.4 (30,709 divided by 22,292). Spread over twenty years, that works out to a compound growth rate of roughly 7 percent a year for Atlanta and about 1.6 percent a year for Savannah. A strong port growing at 1.6 percent cannot keep pace with a railroad city growing at 7, and in twenty years the faster city leaves the slower one far behind. The figures are rounded, but they show how the overtaking happened: a sustained difference in the pace of growth.
What Savannah had
Savannah was founded in 1733 as Georgia's first city. It had a deepwater river port, a handsome plan of squares laid out by the colony's founder, James Oglethorpe, and one of the busiest cotton markets in the South. Cotton grown across the Georgia interior came by river and rail to its wharves, and the city's merchants financed and shipped it. Its own railroad, the Central of Georgia, ran to Macon and carried cotton from the middle of the state to the coast.
Savannah also had something Atlanta lacked: the war spared it. In December 1864 the city surrendered to Sherman's army at the end of the March to the Sea, and its buildings and squares came through intact. In the first years after the war Savannah was the better-preserved and better-capitalized of the two. Asked in 1865 which would be bigger in 1880, almost anyone would have bet on Savannah.
What Atlanta had
Atlanta had the junction. How it began is told in From Terminus to Atlanta: the names of a railroad town. By the 1850s four lines met in the city: north to Chattanooga, east to Augusta, south to Macon and southwest toward West Point on the Alabama line. That arrangement had a basic economic effect. Anything moving between the Midwest and the Atlantic coast, or between the Carolinas and the Gulf, could be routed through Atlanta, and the city became a place where goods were unloaded, stored, sorted, sold and loaded again.
The war did not change that. It proved how valuable the junction was, which is why Atlanta was attacked in 1864 (see The 1864 siege of Atlanta: four months that burned a railroad city), and the railroads were rebuilt faster than almost any other civilian asset because they were the city's reason to exist. New lines followed in the coming decades, and Atlanta's rail system grew into a regional network serving the whole Southeast.
The economy that grew up around the junction differed from Savannah's. Savannah's wealth rested on a single crop and a single stream of exports. Atlanta's rested on distribution: wholesale trade, banking, insurance, printing and, more and more, manufacturing. A warehouse district grew up beside the tracks. The commercial houses that supplied stores across Georgia and the neighboring states set up in Atlanta because a salesman could reach a hundred small towns from there by train. By the 1880s Atlanta had cotton mills, iron foundries, fertilizer works and a growing circle of banks; the Fulton Bag and Cotton Mill, which opened in 1881 and became the center of the Cabbagetown neighborhood described in Cabbagetown, is one example.
How a junction makes a city: an illustration
Say a wholesale grocer in the 1870s wants to supply country stores across north Georgia, east Alabama and the Carolina piedmont. If he locates in Savannah, every shipment to those stores has to go inland on a single line or by wagon, and every customer's order has to come back to the coast. If he locates in Atlanta, a salesman can board a morning train on any of four lines, reach a different set of towns by afternoon, and have the goods follow on the next freight. Each additional store he serves, and each additional line that joins the junction, raises the value of being there. The effect compounds: the grocer draws a banker, the banker draws an insurance agent, the agents draw a newspaper, and the newspaper advertises the next wholesaler. A railroad crossing turns into a market.
It is an illustration, not the record of any one firm, but it describes the mechanism the 1880 census captured. The same logic explains why Atlanta, and not Augusta or Macon, became the largest inland city in Georgia. Augusta and Macon both had railroads, and both were smaller than Atlanta by 1880. The difference was how many lines met in each city and how far each could reach.
What the 1880 census said
The 1880 count put Atlanta at 37,409, which made it Georgia's largest city for the first time. Savannah's 30,709 placed it second. Augusta and Macon were smaller still. The numbers did not make Atlanta a major national city, since plenty of Northern and Midwestern cities were far larger, but they changed how Georgians thought about their state. The center of the economy was moving inland and uphill, away from the coast, and the center of politics had already moved with it.
It changed how Atlantans thought about themselves, too. In the 1880s the city's newspapers and civic organizations waved the census figures at investors, and the habit of advertising Atlanta's growth, which has never stopped, took hold in these years. When the Atlanta Regional Commission or a convention bureau cites a population milestone today, it is following a very old local tradition. The agencies that now track growth are described in The Atlanta Regional Commission and the 11-county map.
The decisions that helped
Several choices amplified the geography:
- The capital. In 1868 the state moved its capital to Atlanta, and in 1877 the constitutional convention confirmed it as permanent. The legislature, state offices, lawyers and lobbyists brought steady business. See When the capital moved from Milledgeville to Atlanta in 1868.
- Schools. The Atlanta University Center institutions were founded between 1865 and 1881 and the Georgia School of Technology was established in 1885. They gave the city an educated workforce, Black and white, and a claim to be a center of learning. See The Atlanta University Center: how a consortium of Black colleges began, 1865 to 1885.
- Exhibitions. Atlanta's leaders staged a series of expositions to advertise the city: a cotton exposition in 1881, another in 1887, and the large Cotton States and International Exposition in 1895. Each brought visitors, investors and publicity, and the 1895 event is covered in The 1895 Cotton States and International Exposition.
- Boosterism. The city's newspapers and civic leaders sold Atlanta as the capital of a "New South," a place of factories, railroads and commerce. Their argument is the subject of Henry Grady and the New South: the case Atlanta made to investors.
What the New South promoters argued
The promoters' case was simple and well aimed. The old South had leaned on cotton and slavery; the war had destroyed the second, and the first alone was an unreliable base. The way forward, they said, was diversification: manufacturing, mining, railroads, and a business-friendly political order that would draw Northern capital. Atlanta, with its rail network and growing industries, was their showcase.
The argument worked in one way and fell short in another. It brought investment and growth, and Atlanta's expansion between 1870 and 1890 is part of the evidence. But the New South program also came with a bargain on race and labor. The promoters generally accepted white political dominance and segregation, and the prosperity they described was unevenly shared. Black Atlantans built their own institutions, including colleges, churches and businesses, in the same decades, often in the face of the exclusion that the New South did not challenge. Both halves are in the record. A critical look at the bargain is in Henry Grady and the New South: the case Atlanta made to investors.
Why Savannah lost the lead
Savannah did not make a mistake so much as occupy a different position. Port cities live on shipping, and in the late nineteenth century the economic center of gravity was shifting toward railroads and inland distribution. A port could be a fine business and still grow slowly if its trade was tied to a single crop and its hinterland was fixed. Atlanta's growth depended on the whole region's expansion and on new kinds of activity, which gave it more room to grow.
The contrast is also a reminder that a city's size is partly a function of the networks it joins. Savannah joined a network of ocean trade; Atlanta joined a network of railroads. In the 1880s the railroad network was growing faster.
What it left behind
Atlanta's lead over Savannah has only widened. A century and a half later the metropolitan area has more than six million residents, while Savannah's metro area is a fraction of that. The two cities also complement each other: Savannah's port is one of the nation's busiest container ports and an important outlet for goods moving through Georgia, and Atlanta's logistics industry feeds it. The relationship is explored in Savannah and Atlanta: two Georgia cities that traded places.
For readers who want to see how the census figures look in the city today, Downtown covers the part of the city where the 1880s commercial blocks stood, and Invest Atlanta describes the agency that now works on the city's economic development.