Blog

Who watches the police: the Atlanta Citizen Review Board

Created by ordinance in 2007, amended in 2010 and 2016, with subpoena power since 2010 and jurisdiction over police and corrections officers.

Every large police department has an internal affairs unit, a part of the department that investigates its own officers. Atlanta also has something that sits outside the department: the Atlanta Citizen Review Board, usually shortened to ACRB. It is a civilian body created by city ordinance, charged with looking into complaints of misconduct by the city's sworn police officers and its corrections officers. The board has existed since 2007, has had its powers expanded twice, and in 2025 became the subject of an agreement over how it gets the information it needs. What follows covers what it is, what it can do, and the debate that surrounds civilian oversight in general.

Where it came from

According to the board's own website, the ACRB was established by city ordinance in 2007, and the ordinance was amended in May 2010 and again in May 2016. What that history tells you is that the board is a creature of ordinance, not of the city charter or of state law. An ordinance is something the City Council passes and the mayor signs, and it can be amended by the same process; How an Atlanta ordinance becomes law, step by step traces that route. A body that exists by ordinance has the powers its ordinance gives it, and the 2010 and 2016 amendments show the council coming back to those powers.

Nationally, civilian oversight boards grew out of a recurring worry in American cities that police departments cannot be fully trusted to investigate themselves, and that public confidence depends on someone outside the chain of command reviewing complaints. Models differ widely. Some boards only review how the department handled a complaint. Some conduct their own investigations. Some can recommend discipline; very few can impose it. Where Atlanta's board falls in that range depends on its ordinance, and the text of the ordinance is the controlling source.

Whose conduct it can examine

The ACRB's jurisdiction covers two groups: sworn officers of the Atlanta Police Department and officers of the Atlanta Department of Corrections, the city's detention center. Both groups are employed by the city, and complaints about their conduct can come from residents, from people who were arrested or detained, and from others who witnessed an incident.

The coverage of corrections officers is the part many residents do not know about. People tend to think of oversight in terms of street policing, but the city runs its own detention facility, and a complaint about treatment in a city jail falls in the same category. The Fulton County Jail, by contrast, is run by the county sheriff and is not part of the city's department; its oversight is a different story, covered in The Fulton County Sheriff and the county jail, and what the office does. A person with a complaint about conduct needs to know which agency employs the officer, because that decides whether the city's board is the right place.

The police department itself is profiled in Atlanta Police Department; its headquarters is the Public Safety Headquarters at 226 Peachtree Street SW, and its non-emergency number is 404-658-6666. Emergencies go to 911, as set out in How to reach police, fire and emergency help in Atlanta.

The subpoena power

The board gained subpoena power in 2010, according to its own site. A subpoena is a legal order to produce documents or to appear and testify. For an oversight body, it is the difference between asking and requiring.

Without subpoena power, a review board depends on the cooperation of the people it investigates. An officer can decline an interview, and a department can be slow with records. With it, the board can compel the production of evidence and testimony, subject to the ordinance and to the courts. That is why the 2010 amendment is generally treated as the board's most important expansion. It turned the board from a body that could ask questions into one that could require answers.

The practical limits are worth understanding. A subpoena compels evidence; it does not dictate outcomes. What the board does with what it learns, such as publishing findings or sending recommendations to the chief or the mayor, is set by the ordinance. Readers who want to know what happens after a complaint is investigated should read the ordinance and the board's own descriptions of its process.

The 2025 data-sharing agreement

In 2025, according to the board's materials and to city pages, the ACRB, the police department and the mayor's office signed a memorandum of understanding aimed at improving data sharing. A memorandum of understanding is an agreement between parties that sets out how they will work together. It is not a law and does not change the ordinance, but it can settle practical questions that matter a great deal in oversight work: what records the board gets, how fast, in what format and how it is used.

An agreement like this is needed because oversight runs on information. A board that receives complaints but cannot see the police department's records of the incident, such as reports, video and personnel history, cannot do much more than relay what the complainant says. Agreements about data access are typical in cities that have oversight boards, and how much access is enough is a recurring question.

The debate

Civilian oversight of police is a subject on which reasonable people disagree, and a fair account has to include several views.

Supporters argue that:

  • independent review builds public trust, because findings from outside the department are harder to dismiss as self-protection;
  • a board with subpoena power can get evidence that voluntary cooperation would not produce;
  • the process gives residents a place to bring complaints other than the department they are complaining about.

Skeptics argue that:

  • a board without power to impose discipline can only recommend, and recommendations can be ignored;
  • civilian reviewers may lack the training to evaluate police decisions made in seconds;
  • investigations take time, and officers' representatives and some residents worry about the fairness of the process to the officers involved.

Many who study the subject emphasize that outcomes turn on details: how the board is staffed and funded, how its members are chosen, what it can access and what happens to its findings. A board that looks strong on paper can be weak in practice if its budget or data access is limited, which is why an agreement on data sharing is a substantive development and not only a bureaucratic one.

This piece takes no position on the merits. The point is that the ACRB sits inside a national argument, and its record is a matter of public information.

How a resident can use it

  1. Know the agency. If the complaint is about an Atlanta police officer or a city corrections officer, the ACRB is the board with jurisdiction. If it is about a county sheriff's deputy, a state trooper or a federal agent, it is not.
  2. Go to the source. The board's website, acrbgov.org, describes how to file a complaint and what information to include. The city's boards and commissions page also lists it.
  3. Keep your own record. Dates, times, places, names or badge numbers where known, and the names of witnesses make a complaint easier to act on.
  4. For an emergency, call 911. A review board does not respond to incidents; it reviews them afterward.

What to watch

Three things are worth following. First, the board's reports, where it publishes them, which show how many complaints it receives and what it finds. Second, whether the 2025 agreement produces the data access it was meant to. Third, any proposal to amend the ordinance again, since the council has already done so twice. Changes to the ordinance would go through the council in the usual way, with committee review and a vote.

The board itself is profiled in Atlanta Citizen Review Board, and the department it oversees in Atlanta Police Department. For the larger frame of how the city's public safety budget is divided, see Reading Atlanta's general fund: what $994.6 million pays for.

A hypothetical, to show where the board fits

Say a resident believes an Atlanta police officer used unnecessary force during a stop. The resident has several routes, and they are not mutually exclusive. The person can report the matter to the police department, whose internal process investigates its own officers. The person can file a complaint with the Citizen Review Board, which is outside the department. The person may also consult a lawyer about a civil claim, or, if a crime may have been committed, contact prosecutors. Each route has its own rules, timelines and outcomes, and the existence of one does not cancel the others.

The Citizen Review Board's role in that picture is to be the civilian check: a place where the review is done by people who are not part of the chain of command. What the board can compel, what it can recommend and what happens next are set by its ordinance. The same sequence applies to a complaint about a city corrections officer.

What the board is not

It is not a court. It does not convict anyone or order damages. It is not the police department's disciplinary system, which has its own procedures for officers. It is not a substitute for 911; it reviews events after they have happened. And it is not the body that oversees the Fulton County Sheriff's Office, which runs the county jail; that office is a separately elected county agency. Keeping these distinctions straight is the difference between sending a complaint to the right place and sending it to the wrong one.

How oversight connects to the rest of city government

The board is one part of a wider structure of public accountability in Atlanta. The City Council sets the board's powers by ordinance and approves the budget that funds it; the mayor signs those measures and, with the council, shapes the budget. The police department's own budget is part of the general fund, and the share that goes to public safety is among the largest, as laid out in Reading Atlanta's general fund: what $994.6 million pays for. A board's effectiveness is partly a function of how much money, staff and access it is given, which means that decisions about oversight are decisions made in the budget cycle and the legislative process.

Residents who want to influence those decisions can follow the council's committee meetings and attend; see How to attend or watch an Atlanta City Council meeting. The public safety training center that opened in 2025, at a reported cost of $118 million, is a separate subject, but it belongs to the same conversation about how the city trains, equips and supervises its officers.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic