Blog

The Central Library and Marcel Breuer: a brutalist landmark Downtown

Atlanta's Central Library, opened in 1980, was Marcel Breuer's last major building. How it replaced a Carnegie library, faced demolition and was renovated.

The building at One Margaret Mitchell Square divides people the minute they see it. It is a ten-level block of precast concrete, its big panels ribbed in a diagonal pattern admirers call corduroy, planted at the corner of a Downtown square named for the author of Gone with the Wind. It has few ordinary windows and a heavy, sculptural profile. Some people have called it ugly. Others rank it among the most important modern buildings in Georgia. It is the Atlanta-Fulton Central Library, and it was the last major building designed by Marcel Breuer, who died the year after it opened.

The building has had three acts: the decision to replace a beloved Carnegie library with a modern one, the fight over whether to replace this building in turn, and the renovation that followed.

The architect

Marcel Breuer was one of the best-known architects of the twentieth century, trained at the Bauhaus design school in Germany and later a teacher there. He is remembered for furniture, including the tubular steel chairs of the 1920s, and for large concrete buildings. His design for the Whitney Museum in New York, finished in 1966, is the building critics most often hold up beside the Atlanta library. Breuer worked on the Atlanta project with Hamilton Smith, and he died on July 1, 1981, a year after the library opened. He missed the dedication in 1980 because of failing health. The library is also his only building in Georgia.

The building it replaced

Atlanta's library tradition did not start as a government project. It grew out of the Young Men's Library Association, a subscription library founded in 1867 that moved among five locations Downtown. In 1902 a Carnegie library, funded by Andrew Carnegie on land the association had donated, opened at the corner of Church and Forsyth Streets. It served the city for about three-quarters of a century and was renovated in 1950 and 1966. Joel Chandler Harris, the author of the Uncle Remus stories, told stories there, and Margaret Mitchell was a frequent patron, a connection that explains the name of the square.

By the late 1960s the library system wanted a larger building. A bond referendum was talked about for years, and in 1975 voters approved $19 million for a replacement. The Carnegie library came down in 1977, and during construction the staff worked from temporary space on Pryor Street. The new Central Library was dedicated on May 25, 1980, and opened to the public two days later. The irony is plain: a modern landmark replaced an older one, and tearing down a Carnegie library to make room for a Breuer building is the kind of trade preservationists would later argue about in the other direction.

What the building is

The library's own description gives the main facts. The building has ten levels and about 272,000 square feet. It is built of precast concrete, and the exterior panels are laid in the diagonal corduroy pattern, with granite pieces embedded in the surface to give the concrete texture and color. Skylights bring natural light to the core of the building, including the stairway linking the second through fourth floors. Other accounts describe it as built to hold about a thousand users and a million volumes, and it includes a theater of roughly 300 seats and a private outdoor courtyard. The Whitney comparison is no accident: both buildings use heavy, inward-looking concrete forms with carefully shaped openings, a style critics group under the label brutalism, from the French for raw concrete.

A building like this was made to be a fortress for books, with controlled light and a solid exterior. That was an asset in 1980 and a headache later. It was costly to maintain, and a restaurant on the premises closed in the late 1990s.

Downtown in the modernist moment

The library belongs to a period when Downtown Atlanta was being remade in a modern idiom. The 1960s and 1970s brought large-scale projects such as the Peachtree Center complex and the Hyatt Regency, whose multi-story atrium opened in 1967, and a general embrace of concrete, glass and megastructure. The Central Library is the most austere of the group. It does not use the glass atriums and bright spaces of its neighbors. It stands with its back to the street and offers a plaza on its side, a deliberate choice, though one that has not always put visitors at ease. Downtown describes the district around it, and Five Points and the zero milepost, where the railroad made a city explains how the area developed.

The fight over the building

In the early 2000s, the library system's master plan, drafted in 2005, called for a major capital program funded by a bond. A $275 million bond approved in 2008 included $50 million to renovate the Central Library. By 2016 the bonds were due to be issued, and a question hung over the project: renovate Breuer's building, or demolish it and build a new central library on the site?

The debate drew national attention among architects and preservationists. Its main strands:

  • The case for replacement. The building was expensive to run, did not match how people used libraries, and many residents found it forbidding. A new building could be designed for current needs.
  • The case for preservation. The building was a major work by a significant architect and the only one in the state, and its brutalist style belonged to a period of Atlanta's history that was fast disappearing.
  • The political steps. In June 2016 the Atlanta City Council passed a nonbinding resolution calling for a new Central Library at the same address, which alarmed preservationists. In the summer of 2016 the Fulton County Board of Commissioners, which runs the library, voted to use the bond money to rehabilitate the existing building instead, at an estimated cost then of $40 million to $55 million.
  • The aftermath. The Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation placed the library on its Places in Peril list in 2017. The trust has no ownership of the site and no direct role; it listed the building to raise awareness and to call for careful treatment of its interior and exterior and for funds to maintain it long term, saying it worried renovation might not respect Breuer's design.

Notice who decided. The City Council's resolution was nonbinding, and the county commission held the authority, since the county operates the library. That division of responsibility is the same one described in The 34-branch library system: what Atlanta-Fulton offers.

The renovation

The county went ahead with the rehabilitation, and the library system's history page lists what was done. The first six floors received new mechanical systems, flooring, restrooms and lighting. Windows were added on the exterior to bring in more natural light, a change preservation advocates watched closely, since the building's mass and its few openings were central to its character. A new grand staircase now links the lobby with a technology center on the second floor, and above it hangs a sculpture called the Tree of Light, by the artists' studio Luftwerk, in the atrium. On the fifth floor, the renovation added an indoor and outdoor conference center and event space. The work was part of a long period in which the building was refreshed while it stayed in use.

Seeing it today

A visitor can judge the building firsthand. The Central Library is open to the public, and a library card is not needed to look around. A few things reward attention:

  1. The panels. Walk up close to see how the diagonal ribs catch light and how the granite pieces show in the concrete.
  2. The skylights and stairs. Inside, look for the way daylight is brought into the middle of a building with few ordinary windows.
  3. The atrium. The new staircase and sculpture are the most visible additions of the renovation.
  4. The square. Margaret Mitchell Square is a small plaza linking the building to the street, and the library holds the Margaret Mitchell Collection, which came from belongings she bequeathed.

The nearest rail stations are Peachtree Center and Five Points, a short walk away, and How to get a library card in Atlanta-Fulton explains how to get a card if you want to borrow.

A timeline

Year Event
1867 Young Men's Library Association founded
1902 Carnegie library opens on Forsyth Street
1966 Whitney Museum, the Breuer building critics compare to Atlanta's, completed in New York
1975 Voters approve $19 million for a new central library
1977 Carnegie library demolished
May 25, 1980 New Central Library dedicated; opens to the public two days later
July 1, 1981 Marcel Breuer dies
2008 $275 million bond includes $50 million for Central
2016 Council resolution for a new building; county commission votes to renovate
2017 Georgia Trust lists the library as a place in peril

What brutalism means

The word brutalism confuses people who hear it as an insult. It comes from the French term for raw concrete, and it names a style that uses unfinished concrete as its main material and lets the structure and the forms show. Brutalist buildings tend to look heavy and sculptural, and many were public buildings such as libraries, schools and city halls, because concrete was durable and economical. Breuer's work is among the more refined examples: the panels are patterned, the granite fragments add color, and the skylights soften the interior. The style fell out of favor in the decades after it was built and has returned to critical attention in the past few years, which is part of why the Atlanta library's fate drew so much interest.

Why it matters

The Central Library is a case study in how a city decides what to keep. The building is not universally loved, and it has been expensive to run. Yet it is a rare example of a major architect's work in the city and a record of how Atlanta imagined its public institutions in 1980. The decision to renovate rather than replace it means the Downtown skyline keeps a piece of that moment. For the system that runs it, see Atlanta-Fulton Public Library System, and for more of the city's historic places, Atlanta's three skylines: Downtown, Midtown and Buckhead compared shows how Downtown's architecture looks as a whole.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic