Blog

Vine City and English Avenue, neighborhoods beside the stadiums

Two historic Westside neighborhoods sit across Northside Drive from the stadium district; their history, the public record and the redevelopment debate.

Walk out onto the pedestrian bridge that spans Northside Drive from the Vine City MARTA station and the view splits clean down the middle. East is the biggest stadium complex in the state: Mercedes-Benz Stadium, which opened on August 26, 2017, the Georgia World Congress Center and the grounds of the old Georgia Dome. West is a grid of modest houses, churches and empty lots, part of two of the oldest Black neighborhoods in Atlanta, Vine City and English Avenue. A few hundred feet separate them. For decades they have sat on opposite sides of the same city's argument about money, growth and fairness.

What follows is a case study in what happens when a very large public project lands next to a very small community. It lays out the history of the neighborhoods, the public record of the stadium deal and the claims of people on different sides, and leaves the judgment to the reader.

Two neighborhoods with deep roots

Vine City. The land south of Simpson Road was settled at the end of the 1800s by large landowners and became a mostly African American residential area, though there were white subdivisions, schools and churches too. In 1910 Alonzo F. Herndon, founder of Atlanta Life Insurance Company, built his home at 587 University Place; it is on the National Register of Historic Places and open to visitors. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. moved to the area in 1967, and his widow Coretta Scott King lived there until 2004. The neighborhood is bounded by Joseph E. Boone Boulevard and English Avenue on the north, Northside Drive and Downtown on the east, Martin Luther King Jr. Drive and the Atlanta University Center on the south, and Joseph E. Lowery Boulevard and Washington Park on the west. Its 2010 population was 2,785. MARTA's Vine City and Ashby stations serve the Blue and Green lines.

English Avenue. James W. English Jr., the son of an Atlanta mayor, bought the area in 1891 and laid it out as a white working-class neighborhood, also known as Bellwood and Western Heights. Black families began moving north across Simpson Road in the 1920s through the 1940s, and the 1941 Eagan Homes and Herndon Homes public housing projects swelled the Black population. By the middle of the twentieth century it was a middle-class African American neighborhood. Its 2010 population was 3,309. To the west lies Bankhead, whose Bankhead Highway was a commercial corridor at its height in the 1960s.

Both neighborhoods belong to what is generally called the Westside, and both sit close to the Atlanta University Center, which supplied many of their residents and institutions. The Atlanta University Center: a walk through four contiguous campuses describes the campuses.

The creek and the floods

The most stubborn problem in both neighborhoods is water. Repeated flooding has been tied to mismanagement of the Proctor Creek watershed, and the city eventually bought homes that flooded again and again. The cleared land became Rodney Cook Sr. Park, built over several years and reported complete in 2021. The park does double duty as flood control and as a place to sit, and it shows what can happen to a neighborhood's land after repeated loss. The condition of the watershed and of the city's water systems is a larger subject, handled by the Department of Watershed Management; see Department of Watershed Management.

The stadium deal

The Falcons' new stadium was approved in 2013, and the public record runs like this. The city and Fulton County agreed on March 7, 2013, to a maximum public contribution of $200 million, drawn from the hotel-motel tax. The Atlanta City Council approved the deal on March 19, 2013, by a vote of 11 to 4. The NFL approved a $200 million loan to the team on May 21, 2013. The state put in $40 million for parking expansion. Estimates put the total public cost at several times the headline figure through 2050 once financing, maintenance and operations are counted, and public spending was expected to top $700 million. Construction was projected at $1.6 billion in 2016.

A 2012 proposal had put the stadium on a large parking lot in Vine City, less than a mile north of the old Georgia Dome. The final site was a Georgia Dome parking lot, across Northside Drive from the neighborhood. Construction left its mark on the area all the same. Mount Vernon Baptist Church held its last service on March 9, 2014, and was demolished that April. Friendship Baptist Church was demolished and relocated to make room. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive was closed for good where it passed the site. The Georgia Dome came down after the new stadium opened, imploded on November 20, 2017, and its site became The Home Depot Backyard, an 11-acre green space used for tailgating. A $33 million pedestrian bridge now carries people from the Vine City MARTA station across Northside Drive to the stadium.

What supporters argued

Supporters said a modern stadium would keep the Falcons in Atlanta, draw conventions, concerts and national events, and bring jobs and investment to the Westside, an area that had known decades of disinvestment. The city's record as host of large events, from the Super Bowl in 2019 to the 2026 World Cup matches, is part of that case. See How Atlanta wins big events: the 1996 Olympics, a Super Bowl and the 2026 World Cup.

What critics argued

Critics said the public money should have gone to the neighborhoods directly, that stadium-related development could drive up property values and push out long-time residents, and that earlier promises to the Westside had gone unkept. The neighborhoods' own decline gave the argument weight, including a 2012 news report that on some streets more houses were boarded up than lived in. Whether the stadium has helped or harmed is not a settled question, and the answer depends on which measures you pick and over what stretch of time.

Responses on the ground

Several efforts have tried to meet the neighborhoods' needs. Westside Works, a nonprofit job-training center, opened in 2014 at the former E.R. Carter School site on Joseph E. Lowery Boulevard. The Westside Future Fund describes itself as a place-based nonprofit that aims to restore neighborhoods into thriving mixed-income communities without displacing the people who have long called them home. It covers five areas: Vine City, English Avenue, the Atlanta University Center, Ashview Heights and Just Us. Its programs include a housing initiative called Home on the Westside, along with historic renovations and property tax assistance, and its stated focus areas are mixed-income housing, cradle-to-career education, health and well-being, and safety and security.

There was an earlier try at renewal. The Historic Westside Village project was announced in 1999 as a $130 million effort. A grocery store opened there in May 2002 and closed in December 2009; a Walmart was announced in December 2010 and opened in January 2013. In 2018 Friendship Baptist Church held talks with developers about Downtown West, a project next to the stadium.

The people who live in the neighborhoods, and the researchers who track outcomes over time, are the best judges of how those efforts have gone.

Places to see

A visitor trying to understand the neighborhoods can start with three places. The Herndon Home on University Place, built in 1910 by the founder of Atlanta Life Insurance Company, is on the National Register of Historic Places and open to visitors; it ties the neighborhood to the Sweet Auburn story told in Sweet Auburn Avenue, a walk through Black Atlanta's main street. Rodney Cook Sr. Park shows what the city did with land that flooded. And the pedestrian bridge from the Vine City MARTA station, which links the neighborhood side to the stadium side, puts the two Atlantas in a single frame. Hours and tours change, so check the home's and the park's own websites.

The MARTA station is the easiest way in. The Vine City and Ashby stations serve the Blue and Green lines, and the Dome/GWCC/CNN station on the stadium side is a short walk away. For fares and schedules, see MARTA. These are residential streets, so visitors should mind the people who live there.

Why the case is hard to settle

A reader might expect a straight answer on whether the stadium helped or hurt the neighborhoods. There isn't one, for three reasons.

The decline came first. Vacant houses, flooding and disinvestment in Vine City and English Avenue predate the new stadium by decades. That 2012 report of more boarded-up houses than occupied ones on some streets was written before construction began. Whatever the stadium did has to be measured against a starting point that was already hard.

Many things changed at once. In the same years the Beltline expanded, the city's economy grew, interest rates moved, and the Westside Future Fund and other groups began their work. Pulling apart the effects of one project from the rest is hard, even for professionals.

Different people want different things. A homeowner who wants property values to rise and a renter who fears rising rent are both residents, and they can reach opposite conclusions from the same facts. A resident who prizes new jobs and a resident who prizes stability can both be right about what matters to them.

What is clear is that decisions on big projects are made in public, that the numbers are published, and that residents have used meetings, lawsuits, organizing and the ballot to be heard. The best approach for a reader is to follow the neighborhoods' own organizations and the city's published data, and to hold the claims made in advance up against what is on the ground years later.

Questions the reader can ask

  • Who benefits? For any project, ask which residents, workers and owners see a gain, and how it is measured.
  • Who pays? The stadium's public contribution came from a hotel-motel tax, which visitors largely pay, but the total public cost depends on financing and upkeep over decades.
  • Who stays? The best test of an anti-displacement program is whether long-term residents are still in their homes years later. The Westside Future Fund and the city can say what their programs have achieved to date.
  • What changed on the ground? Compare the streets today with the streets before the stadium, and ask the people who live there.

A short timeline

  • 1891. James W. English Jr. buys the land that becomes English Avenue.
  • 1910. Alonzo Herndon builds his home on University Place.
  • 1941. Eagan Homes and Herndon Homes open.
  • 1967. Dr. King moves to Vine City.
  • March 2013. The city, the county and the council approve the stadium's public contribution.
  • 2014. Westside Works opens; Mount Vernon Baptist Church is demolished.
  • August 26, 2017. Mercedes-Benz Stadium opens.
  • November 20, 2017. The Georgia Dome is imploded.
  • 2021. Rodney Cook Sr. Park is reported complete.

The neighborhoods' own profile is at Vine City. For the downtown district across Northside Drive, see The stadium district: what sports built Downtown, and who paid, and for the neighboring warehouse district, Castleberry Hill, a warehouse district on the edge of Downtown.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic