Blog

What the Olympics did to Atlanta's public housing

How the housing authority went from the nation's first public housing to demolishing all of its family projects by 2011, and what supporters and critics say.

Measured one way, Atlanta ran the most radical public-housing experiment of any large American city. In 1936 it had the first permanent federally built public housing project in the country. In 2011, with the demolition of one of its last large family developments, it became the first major city to tear down all of its family public housing. What sits between those two dates is the push to win and host the 1996 Summer Olympics, and the housing authority's decisions in those years still divide the people who work on housing, the people who study cities and the people who lived in the projects.

Techwood and the early years

The story starts with Techwood Homes, completed in 1936 near the Georgia Institute of Technology and Downtown. It is often called the first permanent public housing project in the United States, and it set a model for federal housing programs. A fuller account of the project and the era is in Techwood Homes: the nation's first federal housing project, 1935.

The Atlanta Housing Authority itself was created in 1938 by the city's Board of Aldermen. It is governed by a five-member board appointed by the mayor and is otherwise independent of city government, a structure that still holds. By 1940 the authority had built six projects for white and Black residents, in separate buildings, with a total of about 4,000 units for roughly 20,000 people. By the end of 1956 it had built twelve projects and cleared 516.8 acres of what the era called slums; public housing held more than 27,000 people, in buildings designed for about 25,000.

The expansion carried a cost that often gets left out. From 1956 to 1966, urban renewal and highway construction displaced almost 67,000 people in Atlanta, most of them Black. Only 11 percent were rehoused in public housing. Public housing was, in other words, both a place to live and part of the machinery that removed older neighborhoods. That history shaped how many residents later viewed any housing plan that began with a demolition.

Why the authority changed course

By the late 1980s many of the authority's projects were in poor repair, and federal officials had counted it among the nation's worst-managed housing authorities. Then came the Olympic bid. When the International Olympic Committee chose Atlanta in 1990 (the vote is covered in From the 1990 bid to the 1996 Games: how Atlanta won the Olympics), the city had six years to show the world a presentable downtown, and some of the oldest public housing stood close to the proposed Olympic venues.

In 1993 Atlanta won its first HOPE VI grant, a federal program that paid to demolish distressed public housing and replace it with mixed-income communities. The grant was first meant to renovate Techwood and a neighboring complex, Clark Howell Homes. Instead Techwood was demolished and replaced with a new community called Centennial Place, named for the Olympic park next door. Techwood had held about 1,100 units; at Centennial Place only about 300 remained for low-income households, with the rest at market rates or for moderate-income families. That pattern of "fewer subsidized units, more market-rate units" became the model for what followed.

In 1994 Renee Glover became chair and chief executive of the authority, and she pushed the approach much further. In 1996 the authority formalized the strategy under the name Mixed-Income Communities. Over the next fifteen years it demolished one family public housing project after another. In 2011 the demolition of Bowen Homes finished the job, making Atlanta the first U.S. city to have eliminated all of its family public housing. The authority's own accounts describe the effort as breaking up concentrations of poverty and replacing physically failing buildings with new communities.

The arithmetic of one redevelopment

The Techwood-to-Centennial Place numbers show how the model worked. Techwood had about 1,100 units. Centennial Place kept about 300 for low-income households. That is about 27 percent of the original count, so roughly seven of every ten of the old subsidized apartments did not come back to the site. The remainder were meant to house higher-income families, and the argument for the design was that a mixed community would be more stable and better maintained. The counterargument is the other 73 percent: those households were handed vouchers or moved elsewhere, and the program's success depended on how well vouchers worked for them in the private rental market.

How vouchers work, in plain terms

A housing choice voucher is a federal subsidy. A family that holds one pays roughly a set share of its income toward rent, and the housing agency pays the landlord the difference up to a limit. The family finds its own apartment, which must pass an inspection and rent at or below the program's limit. The catch, in Georgia as in many states, is that nothing in state law requires a private landlord to rent to a voucher holder, and rents in popular areas can run past the program's limit. A voucher is a promise of help, not a guarantee of a home; whether it works depends on the rental market and on the family's time and resources to search. The state's broader landlord-tenant framework, which includes the preemption of local rent control, is covered in Renting in Atlanta: what Georgia law covers and where to turn.

What supporters say

Supporters of the program make several arguments, and each carries weight.

  • The buildings were failing. Many of the older projects had serious maintenance problems and were cut off from jobs, shops and schools.
  • Concentrated poverty hurts. The theory behind HOPE VI, shared by many housing researchers, is that when poor families are clustered in a few large complexes, the surrounding neighborhood loses services and opportunities, and that mixing incomes helps.
  • Vouchers give choice. A housing voucher lets a family pick a home on the private market instead of being limited to a particular project.
  • The sites became valuable again. The land in Downtown and Midtown was among the most valuable in the region, and mixed-income development brought investment to blocks that had been written off.

The authority today describes itself as the largest housing authority in Georgia, serving nearly 27,000 low-income households, about 43,000 people, through its owned communities, vouchers and down-payment assistance, as laid out in Atlanta Housing. A further history is in Atlanta Housing, from public housing projects to vouchers.

What critics say

Critics, including many former residents and some researchers, make an equally detailed set of arguments.

  • Only a fraction of the units came back. Only a small share of the demolished units were replaced in the new mixed-income communities. After the 2008 recession the authority canceled several rebuilding plans, leaving cleared land idle.
  • Vouchers are not guaranteed to work. Not all displaced residents qualified for a voucher, and landlords are generally not required to accept one. Reports at the time said many residents left the city or lost stable housing.
  • Relocation concentrated poverty elsewhere. In 2008 residents and researchers alleged that voucher relocation had sent displaced families to a narrow set of neighborhoods, concentrated by race and income. That led to a fair-housing complaint filed with the federal housing department.
  • The Olympics set the timetable. The critique is that a deadline created for a sports event, not a housing plan, drove the pace and the order of demolitions.
  • Leadership problems. In 2016 reporting found that top executives had exceeded a federal pay cap by supplementing their salaries through a nonprofit that holds a federal housing contract, which added to doubts about the authority's governance.

Because the authority is partly independent of City Hall, voters can't hold it accountable the way they can the mayor or the council, a point to keep in mind when reading about any later decision.

Four terms worth knowing

  • HOPE VI: The federal program that financed the demolition of distressed projects and their replacement with new housing, mostly mixed-income.
  • Mixed-Income Communities: The authority's name, from 1996, for its replacement model: some subsidized units, some moderate-income, some at market rates, on the same site.
  • Moving to Work: A federal designation, held by Atlanta Housing, that gives an authority more flexibility to design its own programs than standard rules allow.
  • Voucher: A portable subsidy a household takes to a private landlord, described above.

These terms matter because the debate about Atlanta often turns on which of them is under fire. A person can think vouchers are a good tool and still think the demolitions went too far, or hold the opposite view.

The state of the question today

The authority reported in 2017 that it served about 23,180 households; its own current description gives a larger figure, nearly 27,000, which includes more programs than it used to count. Either way, the authority now works through vouchers and mixed-income partnerships, not through the traditional model of large city-owned projects. The relationship between rent and wages in the city, and the limits on what the city can do about rents, are the subject of Why Atlanta cannot cap rents, and the Georgia law behind the ban. The city's newer tools, including tax allocation districts and a neighborhood reinvestment fund, are described in Atlanta's affordable-housing tools: TADs, vouchers and the NRI.

Anyone who wants to see the change on the ground can walk the blocks around Centennial Olympic Park and the Techwood area in Downtown, where the street grid follows the old projects but the buildings are all new. The question Atlanta leaves for other cities is plain and unresolved: does a program that improves the buildings and the mix of incomes on a site justify the loss of subsidized units and the dislocation of the people who lived there? Atlanta's data, and its residents, give both sides material.

Where the housing story connects to the rest of the city

The public-housing question ties into almost every other part of the city's recent history. The land that was cleared lies near Downtown, where the Olympic park and the convention district are, and the story of that area is in Centennial Olympic Park after the Games. The citywide shifts in who lives where are in Leaving the city and coming back: Atlanta's population, 1970 to 2020. And the question of how a city should house people with low incomes, in a state that bars local rent regulation, is the long-running subject of The Beltline and housing affordability: what was promised, built and criticized.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic