Blog
Georgia Tech and the 1956 Sugar Bowl: the game that nearly did not happen
A Black fullback, a governor's telegram, a college president's refusal and a 13-1 vote: how the 1956 Sugar Bowl was played in spite of segregation.
Georgia Tech beat Pittsburgh 7-0 in New Orleans on January 2, 1956. In an ordinary bowl season that would be the whole story. This one came with a constitutional-sized argument in the state of Georgia first, over whether a white Southern university could take the field against a team with a Black player on it. Nobody knew how the argument would come out until a few days before the game, and the way it did says a good deal about Atlanta in the middle of the 1950s.
The matchup
The 22nd Sugar Bowl was set for New Year's Day, 1956, a Sunday, and so was moved to Monday, January 2, at Tulane Stadium. Georgia Tech, coached by Bobby Dodd, arrived ranked seventh in the country at 8-1-1. The University of Pittsburgh, coached by John Michelosen, was ranked 11th at 7-3. Both teams were invited in the usual way, and the invitation set up the unusual part: Pitt's roster included Bobby Grier, a Black fullback and linebacker.
In 1956 the Deep South's bowl games, like most of its sports, were segregated by custom, and Georgia's political leadership treated segregation as a core commitment. A Black player on the field in New Orleans, against a team from the University System of Georgia, was bound to be a flashpoint, and it was.
The governor's telegram
Marvin Griffin was governor of Georgia. The record shows he had told Dodd and Georgia Tech's president that the game could go ahead, and then took a harder public position. On December 2, 1955, he sent a telegram to the Board of Regents, which governed the state's public colleges, urging that Georgia Tech not play. Its best-remembered line said "the South stands at Armageddon."
The telegram was no private note. It was released, and it was meant to rally opposition. It also put the Board of Regents in the middle, because Georgia Tech was a state institution and the governor was effectively telling the board to cancel one of its university's biggest games of the year.
President Van Leer's refusal
The head of the Georgia Institute of Technology was Blake R. Van Leer, who had come to Georgia Tech as president in 1944 and who was an engineer, not a politician. He refused to withdraw. By the account repeated ever since, he told the Regents that either Georgia Tech would go to the Sugar Bowl or they could find another president. Governor Griffin later asked for his replacement.
Van Leer's position was practical as much as ideological. Georgia Tech had accepted the invitation, its football team had earned the bid, and its coach and players had no objection to the opponent. Pulling out would have meant forfeiting a major bowl and the revenue and prestige that went with it, all to avoid playing against a man because of his race.
The students take to the street
The governor's telegram arrived on a Friday. That night about 2,000 Georgia Tech students gathered on campus in what began as a protest and spread. They were not protesting for integration. They were protesting the governor's attempt to keep the team from playing, and it came out as a mix of football fan loyalty and student rowdiness that turned into a riot. They marched to the governor's mansion and stayed until about 3:30 in the morning.
The crowd broke up after a state legislator, Milton "Muggsy" Smith, told them the game would be played. That promise, handed to a crowd of angry college students in the middle of the night, was premature, but it turned out to be right.
The protest is easy to misread. It was not a civil rights demonstration. The crowd wanted its football game, and its motive was school pride and resentment of political interference. It mattered anyway, because it showed the governor and the Regents that a state-supported university's students would not back him, and because it fell during the very week the Regents were deciding.
The vote
On December 5, 1955, three days after the telegram, the Board of Regents voted 13-1 to let Georgia Tech go to the Sugar Bowl. The vote did not endorse integration. The state's colleges stayed segregated for years afterward. What the vote decided was narrower: that a Georgia team could take the field against a Black opponent in another state.
That narrower decision is what makes the episode a turning point and not a final one. It separated the question of competition from the question of enrollment. Atlanta's schools did not integrate until years later, and Georgia Tech admitted its first Black students in 1961.
The game
The game was played with Bobby Grier on the field, and it became the first integrated Sugar Bowl and the first integrated bowl game in the Deep South. Attendance was between roughly 76,500 and 80,000, depending on the count.
Georgia Tech won 7-0. The only touchdown came after a disputed call: a 31-yard pass interference penalty on Grier, who was covering a receiver, put Georgia Tech at Pittsburgh's one-yard line, and Wade Mitchell scored from there. The call has been argued about ever since. The referee later said it was a mistake, though he denied it was intentional, and Grier himself protested at the time while still praising the Georgia Tech players for how they treated him on the field. Pittsburgh outgained Georgia Tech, 311 yards to 142, but lost two fumbles and was penalized 72 yards. Grier led all rushers in the game with 51 yards, and Georgia Tech's Franklin Brooks was named the most valuable player.
The days in order
The sequence is short enough to lay out, and the speed of it is part of the story.
- Early December 1955: Georgia Tech accepts the Sugar Bowl bid. Pittsburgh, with Bobby Grier on its roster, accepts the other slot.
- December 2, 1955 (Friday): Governor Griffin sends the telegram to the Board of Regents. About 2,000 Georgia Tech students protest, and the crowd moves on to the governor's mansion and remains until about 3:30 a.m.
- December 5, 1955 (Monday): the Regents vote 13-1 to let the game proceed.
- January 2, 1956: the game is played at Tulane Stadium in New Orleans, with Georgia Tech winning 7-0.
- Mid-January 1956: Blake Van Leer dies of a heart attack, about two weeks after the game.
- July 16, 1956: Louisiana's governor signs the law banning interracial sports in the state.
From the telegram to the vote took three days. The movements that came later had nothing like that speed; they took years to change a lunch counter or a school.
Atlanta in 1955
The city where this happened was already a place of contradictions. In 1948 the mayor had ordered the hiring of Atlanta's first eight Black police officers. In 1952 the city had annexed Buckhead and large areas to the south and west, enlarging its population and its tax base. The Atlanta University Center's colleges were operating a few miles from Georgia Tech, among the oldest institutions of Black higher education in the country. Public transportation would not be desegregated until 1959, department-store restaurants by 1961, and the public schools not fully until 1973.
Georgia Tech itself was an all-white school in 1955, and its football program depended on the same regional audience as every other Southern team. Its coach, Bobby Dodd, was one of the most respected men in college football, and his players had nothing against Pittsburgh's. The governor wanted a political statement. The players wanted the game they had earned. The mismatch between those two things is why the episode ended as it did.
What Grier himself said
Grier took the field knowing some of the crowd in the stands, and some of the politicians in the state next door, would rather he were not there. He protested the pass interference call, which he believed was wrong, and the referee eventually conceded the call was an error. He also said Georgia Tech's players had treated him fairly in the game, which was not a given for a Black player in the Deep South in 1956. His own account was calm, and it has helped shape how the game is remembered: as a game in which the players behaved well and the adults around them did not.
What it cost, and what came after
The people on the Georgia side paid some of the costs. Blake Van Leer died of a heart attack about two weeks after the game, and his family believed the stress of the controversy contributed to it. He was not asked to resign, and he held the president's post at Georgia Tech through the confrontation.
In Louisiana, the backlash came in the form of law. In July 1956 the state legislature passed a statute banning interracial sports in the state, and Governor Earl Long signed it on July 16.
Bobby Grier was elected to the Sugar Bowl Hall of Fame in 2019, 63 years after he played in the game. His induction is a late recognition of what he went through, and it makes the event a more public part of the Sugar Bowl's own history.
Why it belongs to Atlanta's story
The 1956 game happened in New Orleans, but it began in Georgia, and the people who decided its fate were in Atlanta: the governor in the State Capitol, the Regents in their board room, the Georgia Tech president on his campus in Midtown, the students in the streets between Tech and the Mansion. The story belongs to a particular moment, when the city that called itself "too busy to hate" was still a deeply segregated place, and when the first small compromises with segregation came, as they often did in the South, through sports and commerce before they came through schools.
"The city too busy to hate" and its limits: desegregation, 1959 to 1973 puts that phrase in context, and The 1960 lunch-counter sit-ins and the arrest of Dr. King follows the movement that turned the arguments of the 1950s into direct action four years later. The historically Black colleges just west of the Georgia Tech campus, covered in The Atlanta University Center: how a consortium of Black colleges began, 1865 to 1885, were part of the same city, and the students there were organizing the sit-ins of 1960.
How to read it today
The Sugar Bowl story is often told as a triumph, and the facts support part of that account: a university president held his ground, the Regents voted overwhelmingly to play, and a Black athlete took the field. It is also fair to say the larger system stayed in place, that the students who marched were mostly defending their football season, and that the political cost of a small step was a heart attack and a new state law.
For a visitor to Georgia Tech today, the place to start is the campus, where the football team plays at Bobby Dodd Stadium at Historic Grant Field, named for the coach who led the 1956 team. The larger context of football in the city, from the Peach Bowl to the SEC championship game, is in College football in Atlanta: the Peach Bowl and the big games.