Blog
"The city too busy to hate" and its limits: desegregation, 1959 to 1973
Where Atlanta's slogan came from, what changed under mayors Hartsfield and Allen between 1959 and 1973, and where the record fell short of the image.
Atlanta has called itself many things, but few slogans have lasted as long or been picked at as much as "the city too busy to hate." The phrase is usually credited to Mayor William B. Hartsfield, who used it in the late 1950s for a city that wanted to be known for commerce and not for racial conflict. It was a deliberate piece of civic marketing, and it also described a real strategy: negotiate quietly, avoid violence, keep business moving. The strategy produced some real change. It also papered over a good deal that had not changed. A fair account looks at both.
Where the phrase came from
Hartsfield was mayor for most of the years between 1937 and 1962, and he understood that Atlanta's growth rode on its reputation. The city was competing with other Southern cities for investment, conventions and airline routes, and a name for riots or bombings could cost it. Hartsfield's way was to work with a small group of white business leaders and moderate Black leaders to settle disputes before they turned into crises.
The slogan boiled that approach down. Atlanta, it said, was too occupied with building and trading to waste energy on racial hatred. It was a promise to businesses as much as a statement about the city's heart, and it sat easily beside the New South promotion of earlier generations, discussed in Henry Grady and the New South: the case Atlanta made to investors.
The mayor who followed, Ivan Allen Jr., a businessman and former president of the Chamber of Commerce, carried the approach forward and, in some ways, went further.
What changed
Between 1959 and 1973 Atlanta desegregated its public life in a series of steps. Most were taken under pressure from Black Atlantans, and most were made possible by the mix of protest and negotiation this period is known for.
| Year | Change |
|---|---|
| 1948 | The city hires its first eight Black police officers |
| 1959 | Public transit is desegregated |
| 1961 | Nine Black students enter four formerly white high schools; Rich's and other downtown restaurants open to Black customers after the sit-in agreement |
| 1962 | Allen takes office, orders segregation signs removed at City Hall and desegregates the cafeteria |
| 1963 | Movie theaters desegregate; Allen testifies in Washington in support of the Civil Rights Act |
| 1964 | Fourteen major hotels and motels pledge to take reservations regardless of race, by January |
| 1973 | A school desegregation settlement; Maynard Jackson is elected mayor |
Several of these deserve more detail.
The first steps. The hiring of Atlanta's first eight Black police officers in 1948 is covered in The first eight Black police officers, 1948. In 1959, after a court challenge, buses and other public transportation were desegregated.
The students and the lunch counters. The 1960 sit-ins forced the next stage; the story is in The 1960 lunch-counter sit-ins and the arrest of Dr. King. The March 1961 agreement tied the desegregation of downtown counters to the integration of the schools that fall, and the counters did open in 1961.
The schools. In the fall of 1961 nine Black students entered four previously all-white high schools. It was a small beginning, called token desegregation, and it passed without the violence other Southern cities had seen. Georgia's lawmakers had considered closing schools rather than integrating them, and the state backed away from that policy before the school year began. Real integration of the school system came slowly; a 1973 settlement is usually treated as the end of the court fight, and it came with a trade-off described below.
Mayor Allen. Ivan Allen Jr. took office in 1962 and moved early. On his first day he ordered "white" and "colored" signs removed from City Hall and the cafeteria desegregated. He hired Black firefighters and authorized Black police officers to arrest white people. He negotiated with the owners of private and public facilities to open them to Black customers; by January 1964, 14 major hotels and motels had pledged to take reservations regardless of race. In July 1963, at President John F. Kennedy's request, Allen testified before Congress in favor of the bill that became the Civil Rights Act of 1964. He was the only prominent white elected official from the Deep South to do so, and the testimony brought him death threats and a year of police protection for his family.
Atlanta also hosted a test of the new law. A motel near Downtown challenged the part of the Civil Rights Act that banned discrimination in public accommodations, and the Supreme Court upheld the law in 1964 in a case named for the Atlanta motel.
The record that did not fit the slogan
The slogan describes the part of the record the city's leaders wanted to stress. A fair account has to include the parts that do not fit.
Violence did not stop. The city had seen the 1906 riot, the lynching of Leo Frank in 1915 and the bombing of The Temple in 1958, covered in The 1906 Atlanta race riot, The Leo Frank case, 1913 to 1915 and The 1958 bombing of The Temple on Peachtree Street. The bombing came only months before the slogan became widely used. A city that was "too busy to hate" had hatred enough to bomb a synagogue.
Change was slow and pressured. Most of the steps the slogan is credited with followed protests, boycotts and lawsuits. The students who sat in, were arrested and organized a boycott did the work that forced the agreements. The city's leaders did make those agreements, but a reader should not mistake the settlement for the cause.
Housing and neighborhoods were another story. In the early 1960s, as Black families moved into formerly white neighborhoods on the southwest side, city leaders put up road barricades on Peyton Road, in the Cascade Heights area, to limit contact between the neighborhoods. The barricades became known as "Atlanta's Berlin Wall." Allen, who had put them up, refused to remove them until a court ordered it. The episode shows how the same mayor could act as a moderate in one setting and a segregationist in another. A related case is the story of two southwest neighborhoods, told in Collier Heights and Cascade Heights, Atlanta's Black middle-class suburbs.
Urban renewal and highways displaced Black residents. The interstates built through the middle of the city in the 1950s and 1960s and the redevelopment projects of the era destroyed or divided many neighborhoods, and a large share of the people displaced were Black. The stadium Allen championed in the mid-1960s, which helped bring the Braves and the Falcons to Atlanta, required the demolition of a Black neighborhood, a fact Black leaders criticized at the time. The neighborhood is the subject of Summerhill and Mechanicsville, two neighborhoods south of Downtown compared.
Not all disorder was avoided. In September 1966 tensions boiled over in Summerhill after a police shooting, and Allen went into the streets to appeal for calm. The mayor's personal courage was widely noted, and the underlying grievances about policing and housing remained.
The population behind the politics
Two demographic facts run under the whole story. In 1952 the city annexed Buckhead and large areas to the northwest, southwest and south, expanding its boundaries and adding many residents, most of them white; the annexation is covered in buckhead and the 1952 annexation: how the uptown district joined the city. Historians note that it helped keep white voters a majority of the city's electorate for some years longer than they would otherwise have been, which shaped how much leverage Black leaders had at the ballot box in the late 1950s and early 1960s.
Then the numbers shifted. As white families moved to the suburbs through the 1960s, the city's Black population grew as a share of the whole, and by 1970 Black Atlantans were a majority. That change made the 1973 election possible and changed what "too busy to hate" could mean: a city whose voters were mostly Black had a different relationship to its own slogan than a city whose voters were mostly white. The movement of residents out of the city and back is told in Leaving the city and coming back: Atlanta's population, 1970 to 2020.
The 1973 school settlement
The history of school desegregation in Atlanta shows both the strengths and the limits of the city's approach. By the early 1970s, Atlanta's schools had become majority Black as white families moved to the suburbs, and the courts and civil rights groups were pressing for citywide integration. In 1973 a settlement was reached that gave the Black community control of the school administration, with the appointment of the system's first Black superintendent, in exchange for a plan that did not require extensive busing to integrate the schools. Supporters saw a practical outcome that put Black educators in charge. Critics, including some within the NAACP, saw an abandonment of the goal of integrated schools. The disagreement persists.
The same year, Atlanta elected Maynard Jackson as its first Black mayor, a milestone described in The 1973 election that changed City Hall. Black political power in City Hall was in some ways the culmination of the story, and in other ways the start of a new set of questions about who benefits from the city's growth.
Image and record
How should a reader weigh all this? A few points seem fair.
- The slogan was more than a slogan. The city's moderate leaders did make real agreements and did avoid the worst violence that struck other Southern cities. That mattered to the people who were spared.
- It was also an image. The phrase was used to promote the city, and the image gave Atlanta an edge in attracting investment and events. A reputation can be true in part and useful at the same time.
- Black Atlantans had a different view. Many Black leaders pointed out that the slogan described what white leaders wished to be true, and that the city's progress depended on their organizing. The students of the Atlanta University Center did the work that made the agreements possible.
- The record is mixed. The city did better than many places and worse than its slogan suggested.
How the city's growth and its image have fit together since is a recurring theme of the posts on Leaving the city and coming back: Atlanta's population, 1970 to 2020 and Gentrification in Atlanta: a timeline from the freeway fight to the Beltline, and the places where this history can be seen are collected in The civil rights trail in Atlanta: a walking route.