Blog
Summerhill and Mechanicsville, two neighborhoods south of Downtown compared
Two neighborhoods south of Downtown share a border and a stadium history but began differently and have rebuilt in different ways.
Head south from the state Capitol and in a few blocks the glass and steel of the government and business district gives out, and you are in a different Atlanta. East of the Downtown Connector lies Summerhill. West of it, between Interstate 20 and a set of railroad tracks, lies Mechanicsville. Both are old, both were built for people who worked with their hands, and both were reshaped in the twentieth century by the same three forces: highways, urban renewal and stadiums. But they started out differently and have rebuilt differently, and set side by side they show how much the history of one piece of Atlanta depends on which side of an interstate it landed on.
Side by side
| Summerhill | Mechanicsville | |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Directly south of Downtown, between the zoo and the Center Parc Stadium site | Just south of Downtown, west of the Downtown Connector |
| Origins | One of two settlements established after the Civil War by William Jennings, in 1865 | Grew up in the late nineteenth century beside railroad lines; usually dated to 1870 |
| Early residents | Freed slaves and Jewish immigrants | A multiethnic mix of working-class Black residents and middle-class white residents |
| Neighbors | Grant Park, Mechanicsville, Peoplestown | Castleberry Hill and Downtown to the north, Summerhill across the Connector, Pittsburgh to the southwest |
| Defining loss | Homes razed for a stadium and parking lots | Out-migration, crime, and the effects of a stadium and nearby interstates |
Summerhill: freedom, faith and a school
William Jennings founded Summerhill in 1865, in the months after the war ended, as one of two settlements for the newly freed. In its early decades it housed freed slaves and Jewish immigrants alike, and by 1911 two-thirds of the city's Jewish residents are said to have lived there. Take that figure as a sign that the neighborhood was a center of Jewish life, not as an exact count.
The institutions came early. Wood's Chapel and Clarke's Chapel began worship in 1866. In 1867 Frederick Ayer founded a school, which the Atlanta Board of Education bought in 1870 and which became the only public school for Black children in the city. That one fact says a lot about where the neighborhood stood: for a time, the education of Atlanta's Black children ran through a school in Summerhill.
Mechanicsville: a railroad neighborhood
Mechanicsville has a plainer beginning. It sprang up in the late nineteenth century beside several railroad lines just south of Downtown, and it took its name from the mechanics who worked those lines. The usual date is 1870. The community was mixed: working-class Black residents and middle-class white residents lived in the same area, and prominent merchants, including the family that founded the Rich's department store, made their homes there.
Infrastructure draws its present boundaries: Interstate 20 on the north, the Downtown Connector on the east and Southern Railway lines on the southwest. Across I-20 lie Castleberry Hill and Downtown, across the Connector lie Summerhill and Peoplestown, and across the railroad lines lies Pittsburgh. The area falls in a neighborhood planning unit identified as NPU-V, and its ZIP code is 30314. Castleberry Hill, a warehouse district on the edge of Downtown covers the neighbor to the north.
What the stadium did
The two histories meet at the stadium. In the 1960s Atlanta built Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium for its new professional teams, and the Braves played there from 1966 until it was demolished after the 1997 season. By 1965 Summerhill had grown westward after absorbing a neighborhood called Washington-Rawson, whose homes were razed to make room for the stadium and its parking lots. Mechanicsville's decline is blamed on the same causes, the stadium and the interstates, along with the out-migration of middle-class families and crime.
Summerhill also had a violent episode in the mid-1960s. A four-day disturbance followed a police brutality incident; the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee and its leader Stokely Carmichael were accused of inciting it, an accusation that remains contested. It left one person dead and twenty injured. The episode belongs in the record of how fragile relations between the police and the neighborhood were at the time.
The stadium story did not stop in 1997. The stadium that became Centennial Olympic Stadium for the 1996 Games was converted into Turner Field, where the Braves played through 2016. Georgia State University acquired the stadium and its parking lots in January 2017, and the stadium was renamed Georgia State Stadium and later Center Parc Stadium for the Panthers football team. Since 2017 the university has been redeveloping the former parking lots. For the city's wider stadium story, see The stadium district: what sports built Downtown, and who paid.
Revival on both sides
Summerhill has been in rapid revitalization and development since 1996, and Mechanicsville has followed since the 2010s. In Mechanicsville, investors have renovated abandoned homes, new houses are going up, property values are rising, and crime is reported to be improving slowly. Racial diversity, which had declined, is said to be coming back. Those are general descriptions, not official statistics.
Both neighborhoods now face the questions that come with revival: who benefits, who gets displaced and how affordable housing can be kept. Atlanta Housing, from public housing projects to vouchers covers the city's housing authority, whose history crosses both neighborhoods, and Gentrification in Atlanta: a timeline from the freeway fight to the Beltline places them in the wider timeline.
What the comparison shows
One neighborhood's history can look like a local accident. Two next to each other show a pattern.
Infrastructure drew the boundaries. Interstates and rail lines hem in both neighborhoods. I-20 on one side and the Connector on another define what counts as Mechanicsville and what counts as Summerhill. The roads that carried people into Downtown also walled the neighborhoods off from it.
A stadium took land. Both lost homes or population in connection with the stadium era, and both watched the stadium's later conversion change their surroundings.
Church and school anchored them. Summerhill's chapels and school gave it institutions that outlasted the buildings around them. Mechanicsville's merchant families and railroad workers gave it a more commercial origin.
Revival is recent and uneven. Summerhill's dates to 1996, the year of the Olympics; Mechanicsville's to the 2010s. Neither is finished.
How to see them
- Summerhill. Walk the streets near the former stadium site and look at the Georgia State campus development, then head toward Grant Park and watch how the streets change. Summerhill is the neighborhood profile.
- Mechanicsville. Walk the residential streets between I-20 and the rail lines; check the city's NPU-V information for community meetings. Mechanicsville is the profile.
- By transit. MARTA's Garnett and Five Points stations are the nearest rail stops for both areas; see MARTA.
- By history. The Atlanta History Center and local archives hold photographs of the stadium era and of the neighborhoods before the interstates.
A few blocks separate the two. What stands in between is a freeway, and that is part of the story too.
A timeline
- 1865. William Jennings establishes Summerhill as one of two settlements after the war.
- 1866. Wood's Chapel and Clarke's Chapel begin worship.
- 1867. Frederick Ayer founds a school; the Board of Education buys it in 1870 and it becomes the city's only public school for Black children.
- 1870. Mechanicsville is established beside the railroad lines.
- 1911. Two-thirds of Atlanta's Jewish residents are said to live in Summerhill.
- 1965. Summerhill has grown westward after absorbing Washington-Rawson, whose homes are razed for Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium.
- 1966. The Braves begin play at the stadium; a four-day disturbance in Summerhill follows a police incident.
- 1996. The Olympic Stadium hosts the Games and later becomes Turner Field; Summerhill's revitalization is dated from this year.
- After the 1997 season. Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium is demolished.
- 2016. The Braves play their last season at Turner Field.
- January 2017. Georgia State University acquires the stadium and parking lots.
Questions people ask
Are they the same neighborhood? No. They are separate neighborhoods, in different planning units and on opposite sides of the Downtown Connector, even though the same stadium and the same highways run through both histories.
Which has the better transit? Both sit close to Downtown rail stations. The details depend on the address, and MARTA's maps and trip planner are the best guide. For fares, see MARTA's own fares page; as of November 2026 the standard rail fare is $2.50.
How precise are the dates? Neighborhood founding dates tend to be approximate, and several of the changes described here played out over years, not on a single day. Anyone who needs a precise date should check the city's historic records or the Atlanta History Center.
Why do people compare them? Because they sit side by side and carry similar stories with different outcomes. The pairing is a handy way into the history of the whole south side of Downtown, which takes in Peoplestown, Pittsburgh and Castleberry Hill as well.
The interstate between them
The Downtown Connector, where Interstate 75 and Interstate 85 merge through the middle of the city, is the line that divides the two neighborhoods. It carries more than 340,000 vehicles a day, which makes it one of the busiest stretches of road in the Southeast. Its path, together with Interstate 20 north of Mechanicsville, is why the neighborhoods feel like islands. The roads went in during the same decades that urban renewal cleared neighborhoods, and together they cut the districts south of Downtown off from the center of the city. The Downtown Connector: 340,000 vehicles a day on I-75/85 tells the road's story.
Anyone walking from Summerhill to Mechanicsville has to cross the interstate on a bridge or through an underpass. That small errand shows what the road did: two neighborhoods whose histories are knotted together are, in practice, a trip apart.
In the culture and the record
Mechanicsville has a place in popular memory, too. The film ATL features characters who lived in the neighborhood, and the neighborhood has served as shorthand in music and film for a certain kind of Atlanta upbringing. Summerhill turns up in the history of the civil rights era, in the story of the school Ayer founded, and in the record of the 1966 disturbance. Neither neighborhood is only a place where bad things happened or only a place where revival is happening now; each has been a home, with schools, churches and families, through every one of the periods described here.
People who write about neighborhoods like these tend to tell the story in two moments: before the highway and after the revival. The better account runs without a break. People lived in Summerhill and Mechanicsville through the years of decline and are living there through the years of investment, and what they went through in both is part of the history. The city's current approach to neighborhood investment is covered in The Neighborhood Reinvestment Initiative and its new trust fund.