Blog

The 1958 bombing of The Temple on Peachtree Street

The October 12, 1958 dynamite attack on Atlanta's oldest Reform synagogue, the rabbi at its center, the investigation and trials, and the city's response.

The blast came in the dead of night on Sunday, October 12, 1958, and it tore open the side of The Temple, the Reform synagogue on Peachtree Street in Midtown Atlanta. The building was empty, so no one was hurt. By morning the damage showed from the street, and the news was out across the country. The bombing was an attack on a congregation that had been part of Atlanta since before the Civil War, and whose rabbi had become one of the best-known white clergy supporters of racial integration in the South. It was also one of a string of bombings of synagogues, churches and schools in the South in the late 1950s, and the way Atlanta answered became part of the city's reckoning with its own image.

The congregation

The Hebrew Benevolent Congregation, known as The Temple, was founded in 1860 to serve German Jewish immigrants who had settled in Atlanta. It is the oldest Jewish congregation in the city. Over the years it built a succession of homes: a temple at Garnett and Forsyth streets used from 1875 to 1902, a second building at South Pryor and Richardson streets used from 1902 to 1929, and the present building on Peachtree Street, completed in 1931. The move north tracked the city's growth, as Atlanta's merchant families headed out Peachtree toward the new residential districts.

The congregation's members included merchants, lawyers and civic leaders, and the Jewish community had a long record of contributions to the city's business and cultural life. The Leo Frank case had tested that record earlier, shocking Atlanta's Jews in 1913 and 1915; see The Leo Frank case, 1913 to 1915. After that, the community was wary of public conflict. By the 1950s, though, the congregation's leader was ready to speak out.

The rabbi

Jacob M. Rothschild became the congregation's rabbi in 1946 and served until his death in 1973. A Reform rabbi, he believed his faith required him to speak against racial injustice, and in the 1950s, when most white Southern ministers steered clear of the issue, he said publicly that segregation was wrong. He worked with Black ministers and civil rights leaders, Martin Luther King Jr. among them, and he took part in the interracial discussions that were starting in Atlanta. His outspokenness made him and his congregation a visible target.

In the 1950s and 1960s The Temple became a center for civil rights advocacy, as the congregation's own account describes. That role is why the bombing, aimed at a Jewish house of worship, is understood as an attack on both the congregation and the cause it supported.

The night of October 12

Early that Sunday morning a large charge of dynamite went off at the building. The blast blew out one side of the structure and damaged it severely. Because it was an early hour on a Sunday, the building was empty, and nobody was killed or injured. Had the blast come a few hours later, with Sunday school and worship about to begin, the result could have been a disaster.

A caller, according to the news accounts of the time, said that a group calling itself the "Confederate Underground" was responsible, and that it was acting against integration. The claim fit a pattern. In the late 1950s a series of bombings hit the region, aimed at synagogues, Black churches and schools being desegregated, and the perpetrators often belonged to loosely organized groups of segregationists.

A wave of bombings

Atlanta's was no isolated act. The years after the Supreme Court's 1954 school desegregation ruling brought a wave of bombings across the South, aimed at places that symbolized the movement for change. A Birmingham church whose pastor led local civil rights efforts was bombed in December 1956. The Hattie Cotton Elementary School in Nashville was dynamited in September 1957, after a Black child enrolled. A Jewish community center in Jacksonville, Florida, was bombed in March 1958, seven months before the Atlanta attack. Each time the pattern was the same: a night-time attack, no one inside, a phone call claiming credit and an investigation that rarely ended in convictions.

What made the Atlanta case stand out was the target and the city. A synagogue in the South's largest and most self-consciously modern city was a signal that no congregation that spoke out was safe. It also meant the response would come from a city with a powerful newspaper, a business class that cared about its reputation and a Black leadership already organized for change.

Ralph McGill

The editor most closely tied to the response was Ralph McGill of the Atlanta Constitution. McGill had been writing against segregation and lynching since the 1940s, in a daily column read across the South that made him a figure of controversy; segregationists attacked him fiercely, and some Black and white readers praised him as a conscience for the region. His column on the Temple bombing said, in effect, that the people who preached defiance of the law bore a share of the blame when violence followed, and that the community's silence encouraged it. He won the Pulitzer Prize for editorial writing in 1959, and the bombing column is the piece most often cited from that body of work.

The column mattered because it came from the leading newspaper of a state whose official leaders were defending segregation. It gave moderate white Atlantans permission to say aloud what many privately thought, and it made the civic argument for order and decency that Hartsfield and the business community were already making. Not everyone welcomed it; McGill received angry letters and threats, as other editors in the region did in those years.

The response

The city's reaction was swift and, in the public record, strongly critical of the attack. Mayor William B. Hartsfield condemned the bombing and the climate of hatred behind it. Police and the federal government began an investigation. Ralph McGill wrote a front-page column the next day arguing that the bombing was the result of the climate created by politicians who had urged defiance of the courts. His writing on the bombing contributed to the Pulitzer Prize for editorial writing that he won, and it became one of the best-known newspaper columns of the civil rights era.

Atlanta's Christian ministers and many ordinary citizens expressed sympathy for the congregation, and messages came in from around the country. The incident helped prompt a public discussion among Atlanta's business and political leaders about the city's reputation. A city that wanted to be known for commerce and moderation could not afford to be known as a place where synagogues were bombed. That calculation helped shape the city's later argument that Atlanta was "too busy to hate," a slogan examined critically in "The city too busy to hate" and its limits: desegregation, 1959 to 1973.

The investigation and the trials

Arrests came in the weeks after the bombing, and the case went to trial. A man named George Bright was tried, and the first jury could not reach a verdict. He was tried again and acquitted. No one was convicted of the bombing. The outcome has been widely seen as an example of how hard it was to convict segregationist attackers in front of Southern juries in that era, though Atlanta's police and federal agents had taken the investigation seriously. The record of the arrests and trials is available through court and newspaper archives.

The case left an unusual legacy. A mob attack on the Black community in 1906, a lynching in 1915 and a bombing in 1958 together make up a pattern in Atlanta's twentieth-century history, and they are not separate. Each involved the targeting of a minority community in the name of defending a racial order. For the earlier events, see The 1906 Atlanta race riot and The Leo Frank case, 1913 to 1915.

After the bombing

The congregation repaired the building and went on worshipping there, and it stands on Peachtree Street today. The Temple stayed a leader in the civil rights movement. Rothschild kept speaking out, and the congregation welcomed Black and white audiences to discuss integration. The story of that period in Atlanta's faith community is told in Faith and the civil rights movement in Atlanta: pulpits, campuses and a synagogue.

Black ministers and the Jewish community found common cause in these years. The two groups shared a history of persecution, and in Atlanta, as in other Southern cities, Jewish leaders were among the white allies of the movement, though not all members of the community agreed with that position. The disagreement, between those who wanted to speak out and those who feared reprisal, was a real tension within Atlanta's Jewish community, and it is part of the context in which Rothschild's stand mattered.

Why it is remembered

Several things keep the bombing in memory.

  1. It was an attack on a house of worship in the heart of the city. The target was on Peachtree Street, the city's main street, in the middle of the night.
  2. It involved a congregation that had taken a public stand. The rabbi's support for integration was why the attackers chose it.
  3. It prompted a rare, forceful response from Atlanta's newspapers and civic leaders. The result was a public condemnation that helped define a role for moderate white leaders in the city's racial politics.
  4. It ended without a conviction. The failure to convict anyone is a reminder of the limits of the justice system at the time.

Visiting

The Temple's building is in Midtown on Peachtree Street. It is an active house of worship, and visitors should check its website for tours and events instead of walking in unannounced. The surrounding neighborhood is profiled in Midtown, and the broader civil rights history of the city is told in The civil rights trail in Atlanta: a walking route.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic