Blog

The Leo Frank case, 1913 to 1915

The murder of a 13-year-old, a conviction built on one witness, a governor's commutation and a lynching near Marietta, set out from the court record.

It began with the death of a child and ended with what is widely described as the only lynching of a Jewish American in the nation's history. In between came a murder investigation, a trial in Atlanta's Fulton County Superior Court, appeals that reached the United States Supreme Court, a governor's decision to commute a death sentence, and a night in August 1915 when a group of men took Leo Frank from a state prison and hanged him near Marietta. The case shaped Atlanta's Jewish community for generations, helped give rise to a national organization and opened the road to the revival of the Ku Klux Klan. What follows takes the events in order and stays with what the court record supports.

The crime

Mary Phagan was 13. She worked at the National Pencil Company, a factory on Forsyth Street in downtown Atlanta, where she tended a pencil-making machine. On Saturday, April 26, 1913, the day of the city's Confederate Memorial Day observances, she went to the factory to collect her weekly pay. Her body was found early the next morning in the basement. She had been strangled.

The factory's superintendent was Leo Frank, a 29-year-old mechanical engineer from Texas who had grown up in Brooklyn and come to Atlanta to run the factory, in which relatives held a major interest. He was one of the last people known to have seen Mary Phagan alive. Police questioned him and others, and Frank was arrested. On May 24, 1913, a grand jury indicted him for murder.

The case against Frank

The case turned on the testimony of Jim Conley, a Black man who worked as a sweeper at the factory. Police had found notes beside the body, and Conley had been seen near the factory. After questioning, Conley said he had helped Frank move the body and write the notes. He had given investigators several different accounts before the trial, changing details as he went, and he had good reason of his own to shift suspicion to someone else. At the trial he became the prosecution's central witness. The jury was asked to believe a story told by a man whose earlier statements conflicted with each other.

The trial opened on July 28, 1913, in the Fulton County Superior Court, and it ran for about a month. Frank testified in his own defense and denied involvement. The courtroom was packed, and crowds gathered in the streets and in the courthouse. Accounts of the time and later histories describe a hostile atmosphere, with crowds outside the courthouse and pressure on the jury. On August 25 the jury returned a guilty verdict, and the next day the trial judge sentenced Frank to death.

The mood around the case drew on several currents of the time: anger at the death of a young girl, resentment toward a Northern-born factory manager, and antisemitism. Newspapers covered it relentlessly. A populist politician and publisher, Tom Watson, later campaigned against Frank in his own papers in strongly antisemitic terms.

Appeals

The defense appealed, and the case moved through the courts over two years.

  • February 17, 1914. The Georgia Supreme Court denied a new trial by a vote of four to two.
  • April 19, 1915. The United States Supreme Court, in Frank v. Mangum, refused to overturn the conviction, by a vote of seven to two. Two justices, Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. and Charles Evans Hughes, dissented, arguing that a trial dominated by a mob could not be a fair one.

The dissent is remembered as an important statement of the principle that a trial surrounded by mob pressure violates due process. The majority held that the state courts' process had been adequate.

The commutation

With the courts exhausted, Frank's lawyers asked Governor John M. Slaton to commute the sentence. Slaton, whose term was about to end, reviewed the record, visited the factory and weighed new evidence and affidavits. On June 21, 1915, he commuted the sentence to life imprisonment, saying he had doubts about the fairness of the verdict and about Conley's testimony. The decision was deeply unpopular among many white Georgians, and an angry crowd gathered at the governor's residence. Slaton, who had put his political career at risk, left the state for a time after his term ended.

Frank was moved to the state prison farm at Milledgeville, the former capital (see When the capital moved from Milledgeville to Atlanta in 1868). In July another inmate attacked him and cut his throat. He survived.

The lynching

On the night of August 16, 1915, a group of armed men drove to the prison farm, overpowered the staff and took Frank. They drove him roughly 175 miles across the state to the area near Marietta, Mary Phagan's hometown. On the morning of August 17 he was hanged from a tree. A crowd gathered at the site afterward, and photographs and souvenirs of the scene circulated. No one was charged. Many of the participants were known locally, and some were later identified in histories as prominent men of the community.

The lynching shocked many Americans and drew condemnation in newspapers across the country. Frank's body was returned to New York for burial.

The dates at a glance

Date Event
April 26, 1913 Mary Phagan is killed at the National Pencil Company; her body is found the next morning
May 24, 1913 A grand jury indicts Leo Frank
July 28 to August 25, 1913 Trial in Fulton County Superior Court; guilty verdict on August 25
August 26, 1913 Death sentence
February 17, 1914 Georgia Supreme Court denies a new trial, four to two
April 19, 1915 United States Supreme Court denies relief, seven to two
June 21, 1915 Governor Slaton commutes the sentence to life
August 16 and 17, 1915 Frank is taken from the prison farm and lynched near Marietta
1986 State pardon

Jim Conley himself was tried separately and convicted as an accessory after the fact, and received a sentence of one year on a chain gang. The contrast between that sentence and Frank's is the point those who doubt the verdict raise most often.

Atlanta's Jewish community in 1913

The people in the case belonged to a community with deep local roots. Atlanta's Jewish congregations dated from the 1860s, and German Jewish families had become merchants, lawyers and civic leaders. The Hebrew Benevolent Congregation, whose building later became The Temple on Peachtree Street, had a rabbi, David Marx, who spoke publicly in Frank's defense. Frank himself was active in the local chapter of B'nai B'rith, a Jewish fraternal and service organization, and when the trial brought open antisemitism into Atlanta's newspapers and streets, the community's sense of security was shaken. The decades afterward saw a quieter Jewish public presence in the city until the civil rights period, when Rabbi Jacob Rothschild and The Temple took a prominent role in support of desegregation. The 1958 bombing of The Temple on Peachtree Street describes that later chapter.

Consequences

The effects spread in several directions.

  1. Atlanta's Jewish community. The city's Jews, established in Atlanta since before the Civil War and prominent in business and civic life, suffered a profound shock. Many families left Georgia in the years that followed, and those who remained often kept a low profile. The congregation at The Temple, which later became a center of civil rights advocacy, is part of this longer story. See The 1958 bombing of The Temple on Peachtree Street.
  2. The Anti-Defamation League. The B'nai B'rith organization, in the autumn of 1913, created the Anti-Defamation League, partly in response to the trial and the antisemitism it revealed. The ADL became one of the main national groups combating bigotry.
  3. The Klan. In November 1915, a few months after the lynching, a group of men gathered atop Stone Mountain, east of Atlanta, and revived the Ku Klux Klan. Some of the men who gathered were reported to have been among those who took Frank from prison. The second Klan grew to millions of members in the 1920s.
  4. The law. The dissent in Frank v. Mangum helped shape later decisions that protected defendants from mob-dominated trials.

Later developments

The case did not end in 1915. In 1982 a man named Alonzo Mann, who had been an office boy at the pencil factory in 1913 and was then in his eighties, came forward to say that on the day of the murder he had seen Jim Conley carrying the girl's body, and that Conley had threatened him into silence. Mann's account added to a growing body of historical argument that Conley, not Frank, was the killer. Most historians who have studied the case in detail now regard Frank as innocent, although no court has ever made a final finding of guilt or innocence.

In 1986 the Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles issued a pardon to Frank. The board did not declare him innocent and did not rule on guilt. It acknowledged that the state had failed to protect Frank's life and failed to bring his killers to justice, and it granted a pardon in recognition of that failure. Historical markers and exhibits now describe the case, including one near the site of the lynching in Marietta.

How to hold it in mind

The Frank case resists being read as a single story, because it combines several things at once: a child's murder that deserves its own justice, a trial that most modern scholars consider unfair, a governor's act of conscience, a lynching, and the beginnings of institutions that shaped American civil society for the next century. A careful reader can keep all of them in view without minimizing any.

Two points from the record are worth keeping in view. The first is how much weight the prosecution put on a single, shifting witness. The second is how closely the verdict followed the mood outside the courtroom. Both are reasons the case is studied in courses on law, journalism and American history.

For the city's wider record on mob violence and racial and religious prejudice in the same decade, see The 1906 Atlanta race riot, which describes events seven years earlier, and "The city too busy to hate" and its limits: desegregation, 1959 to 1973, which looks at the later efforts to reconcile the city's image with its history. Fulton County Superior Court describes the court where the trial took place. The downtown blocks where the factory stood are part of Downtown.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic