Blog
Myths about the burning of Atlanta in 1864
Who ordered what in 1864: Hood's destruction of supplies on September 1, Sherman's orders of November 11, what survived the fires and how the myth took hold.
Every Atlantan has stood next to a visitor who says it with total confidence: Sherman burned the city to the ground, in one night, and nothing was left. It is the most famous thing that ever happened here, and about the most misremembered. What actually happened was a sequence spread over more than two months, carried out by two opposing armies, and followed by one of the quickest rebuilds the nineteenth-century South ever saw. The city's motto, Resurgens, Latin for "rising again," and the phoenix on its emblem both trace to that story. Here are the common claims, with dates attached.
Myth 1: Sherman burned Atlanta in a single night
There was no single night. The fall of Atlanta in 1864 came in five distinct stages, and a different person gave the orders at each.
July and August: the siege. After the Battle of Atlanta and the fighting that followed, Union forces besieged the city through roughly four months of campaigning, with artillery fire reaching into streets and homes. The fights around the city are covered in The 1864 siege of Atlanta: four months that burned a railroad city and Peachtree Creek, Ezra Church, Jonesboro: the battles around Atlanta. Shelling damaged buildings and killed civilians, but it did not destroy the city.
September 1: the Confederate retreat. Confederate General John Bell Hood abandoned Atlanta on September 1, 1864, after the fighting at Jonesboro cut his last rail supply line. Before leaving, his army destroyed what it could not carry. The best-known act was the blowing up of an ammunition train. Accounts differ on the number of cars, with some counts as low as 28 and others in the dozens, and on whether the explosion came on the evening of September 1 or in the small hours of September 2. The blast was heard for miles, and fires spread to the rolling mill and other buildings near the railroad. George Barnard's famous photograph of the twisted wreck of the train is held by the Library of Congress.
September 2: the surrender. Mayor James Calhoun surrendered the city to Union forces on September 2. The troops marched into a place that had taken a beating but still stood as a working town of homes, shops and churches.
September 7 to November: the occupation. On September 7, Sherman ordered the civilian population out, turning Atlanta into a military post. The mayor and council protested in a letter, and Sherman answered in writing that military needs came first. For the next two months the Union army held the city, used its railroads and got ready for the next campaign.
November 11 onward: the destruction. On November 11, Sherman ordered the destruction of the city's remaining military assets before the army left for the March to the Sea. This is the order the myth is built on. Crews tore up rails, burned depots, warehouses, factories and machine shops, and brought down masonry buildings with gunpowder. Wooden buildings in the business district burned in the days that followed as the army marched out.
So "Sherman burned Atlanta" has one true core, that his army carried out a deliberate and large-scale destruction in November. It also carries three errors: that it happened in one night, that it was the first destruction, and that it was the only one.
Myth 2: Sherman burned civilian homes on purpose
This is the claim historians argue over most, and the answer turns on the word "purpose." Sherman's written orders for the November destruction named military and industrial property: railroads, shops, foundries, depots, stores of supplies and warehouses. The stated aim was to leave nothing in Atlanta that could feed a Confederate army if the Union forces pulled back.
Fire does not honor the line between a depot and a house. Atlanta in 1864 was a town of wood-frame buildings packed close, and a burn in the business district jumped to nearby homes and shops. Individual soldiers also looted and set fires on their own, in the confusion of an army heading out. Estimates of the damage, then and since, run wide. Georgia historical markers cite roughly 40 percent of the city destroyed, while the National Park Service writes that by some estimates two-thirds of the buildings were lost. A precise count does not exist. Nobody counted at the time, and the records of a captured city are thin.
What is clear is that the civilians were already gone. The September evacuation order had emptied many homes, and those who left carried what they could. The place Sherman's army left in November was not a city of residents watching their houses burn. It was a largely emptied town that the army treated as a military asset.
Myth 3: Nothing was left
Plenty was left. Even on the highest estimates a share of the buildings came through, and the destruction fell hardest on the rail center and the business district, so houses and churches in other parts of town were likelier to survive. The railroads, the reason Atlanta existed at all, could be repaired faster than almost anything else. The surviving buildings and the cleared ground gave a returning population something to start from.
The speed of the comeback is part of why the city later took up the phoenix. By 1868 the state capital had moved from Milledgeville to Atlanta, a decision explained in When the capital moved from Milledgeville to Atlanta in 1868. By the 1880 Census Atlanta had passed Savannah as the largest city in Georgia, the subject of How Atlanta outgrew Savannah by 1880. The three historically Black colleges that grew into the Atlanta University Center were founded within five years of the destruction: Atlanta University in 1865, Morehouse's forerunner in 1867 and Clark University in 1869. The story is in The Atlanta University Center: how a consortium of Black colleges began, 1865 to 1885. A city supposedly wiped off the map produced new institutions in the very next decade.
The population gives a sense of the scale. Atlanta had 9,554 residents in the 1860 Census. It was a young railroad town, only a few decades old, and its identity was rails and commerce. When the railroads were rebuilt, the commerce followed. That is the real reason the burning, however large it looms in memory, did not end the city: what made Atlanta worth building in 1837 was still sitting in the ground in 1865, a junction where the lines met.
Myth 4: Hood and the Confederates did no damage of their own
The version that blames only Sherman leaves out the first fire. Hood's destruction of the ammunition train, and of the supplies and shops in the rail yard, on the night of September 1 and 2 was deliberate, ordered by a Confederate commander who did not want the material falling to the enemy. The explosion damaged nearby buildings, and the flames reached other parts of the rail district. It was a normal act of war for a retreating army, and the same logic drove Sherman's order in November. Each side was destroying what the other could use.
That matters for how the story gets told. The Union army's later destruction was larger and more systematic, but an account that starts with Sherman skips a fire that came first, and that the city's own defenders set.
Myth 5: Gone with the Wind shows what happened
Margaret Mitchell's novel, set in Atlanta and published in 1936, and the film that premiered at Loew's Grand Theatre on December 15, 1939, gave the world a vivid picture of Atlanta aflame, the depot lighting up the sky. That picture is the main reason the myth is so hard to kill. The famous scene was shot on a Hollywood studio lot, not in Georgia, and it squeezes the fires of September 1864 into one dramatic night. The premiere itself, and the fact that Hattie McDaniel was barred from the event by segregation, belong to a different story, told in Gone with the Wind comes to Loew's Grand: the 1939 premiere, and the author's place in the city's memory is in Margaret Mitchell and Atlanta's literary memory.
A work of fiction folded two months of events into one night because a story needs a climax. History does not have one. It has a surrender, an order, an evacuation, a second order and a march.
Myth 6: The city has never recovered its past
The opposite error says the war erased Atlanta's history. Much of the pre-1864 city is gone, but the war did not take everything, and later demolition took more. The city's nineteenth-century story lives on in street names, in the railroad geography around Five Points, where the "zero milepost" of the Western and Atlantic Railroad was set in 1837, and in the memory of the place itself. From Terminus to Atlanta: the names of a railroad town follows how the settlement was named and renamed. The phoenix, the central image of the city seal and the motto, is explained in Resurgens: Atlanta's phoenix motto, its nicknames and the city in a forest.
How to check a claim about 1864
When somebody tells an Atlanta war story, three questions sort most of the myth from the record:
- Which date? September 1 and 2 was the Confederate withdrawal and the first fires. November 11 and after was the Union destruction.
- Whose order? Hood ordered the destruction of supplies on the way out. Sherman ordered the destruction of what remained in the city when he left.
- What was the target? Military and railroad property was the stated aim. Houses burned where fire spread or where soldiers acted without orders.
Atlanta understands itself, in part, as a city that lost most of what it had and built it back. The facts are plainer and harder than the legend, and they belong to the people who lived through them.