Blog

September 1864: the surrender of Atlanta and the order to leave

A day-by-day timeline from Hood's night retreat on September 1 to the civilian exodus and the November 1864 destruction, with the letters that argued over it.

The four-month campaign described in The 1864 siege of Atlanta: four months that burned a railroad city ended in fewer than seventy-two hours. The decisive battle was fought south of the city, at Jonesboro, and the city itself changed hands with almost no fighting. What came next was in some ways harder on Atlantans than the siege: a military occupation, an order to leave their homes, and a deliberate destruction of the city's rail and industrial assets two months later. Here are those weeks day by day, on the dates the standard histories give.

August 31 to September 1: the last line is cut

On August 31, 1864, Confederate troops under Lieutenant General William J. Hardee attacked the Union forces that had swung south and reached the Macon and Western Railroad at Jonesboro. The attack failed. The next day, September 1, Union troops attacked and drove the Confederates from their position. The railroad was now in Union hands. It was the last of the four lines into Atlanta the Confederates had still been using, and with it gone the army in the city could not be supplied.

General John Bell Hood understood what that meant. Atlanta was lost unless the army could escape.

The night of September 1: Hood leaves

Hood ordered the evacuation of Atlanta on the evening of September 1. His troops marched out of the city to the south, where they could join the force that had fought at Jonesboro, and left behind anything that could not be moved. His engineers destroyed railroad stock and supplies so the Union army could not use them. The largest act of demolition involved a train of 81 cars loaded with ammunition and ordnance. When it was set on fire the explosions went on for hours. Residents later described a night of blasts that shook the ground and lit the sky, and many remembered it more vividly than the battles of July.

For the civilians who stayed, the night was alarming and confusing. The Confederate army was leaving, the Union army had not arrived, and nobody in charge of the city could be sure what would come next.

September 2: the surrender

On the morning of September 2, the mayor, James M. Calhoun, rode out with a small group of citizens, including William Markham, Jonathan Norcross and Edward Rawson. They met a captain on the staff of Major General Henry W. Slocum, whose corps was the first Union force to approach the city from the north. Calhoun surrendered Atlanta and asked for protection for noncombatants and private property. Sherman himself was at Jonesboro and was not present for the formal surrender; Union troops of Slocum's corps entered the city that day.

The surrender cost almost nothing in blood, because Hood's army had already left. The cost came afterward.

September 3: "Atlanta is ours"

On September 3, Sherman sent a short telegram to Washington: "Atlanta is ours, and fairly won." The news changed the political calendar of the North. The summer of 1864 had been grim for the Union, with huge casualties in Virginia and little visible progress, and the Democratic opposition had been gaining strength on a message that the war was failing. The capture of Atlanta altered that picture. President Lincoln marked the victories at Atlanta and at Mobile Bay with a proclamation of thanksgiving and ordered salutes fired. Lincoln was reelected in November, and historians widely count the fall of Atlanta as an important reason.

September 4 to 6: the army settles in

Sherman, still at Jonesboro, ordered his army to concentrate in and around Atlanta and made it clear in an order on September 4 that the troops would occupy the city and the country around it while he planned the next campaign. His army was exhausted after four months, and he wanted to rest it. Most of the troops camped around the city; Slocum's XX Corps held the city itself. The Union army had taken possession of a city still burning in places, with the railroad yards ruined by Hood's demolition.

September 7: the order

On September 7, Sherman moved his headquarters into Atlanta and told the Confederate commander, Hood, that he intended to remove the city's remaining population. In a letter to Hood he proposed to send civilians out of the city, some north and some south, and asked Hood to arrange a truce so that those who wished to go south could do so safely. He followed with a formal order making the removal mandatory. The order applied to all non-military personnel, including families who had lived in Atlanta for years and many who had been refugees there.

Sherman's reasons, as he gave them, were military. He wanted to use Atlanta as a base and a fortress. He did not want to feed civilians, and he did not want his army's movements and plans visible to a population that might include Confederate sympathizers or spies. He argued that the war would be shortened by treating Atlanta as a military post and not a town.

September 9 to 12: the letters

The order set off an exchange of letters that ranks among the best-known documents of the Civil War.

  • Hood's reply (September 9). Hood wrote to protest. He said the plan was without precedent in his reading of history and described it with the strongest language he could use, calling it a measure of cruelty, and he said he would cooperate in the evacuation only under protest.
  • The Atlanta leaders' appeal (September 11). The mayor, Calhoun, and two members of the city council, Ezra Mayo and E. E. Rawson, wrote to Sherman asking him to reconsider. They pointed out that many residents were women, children, the elderly and the sick, that winter was coming, that some had no place to go, and that the sudden displacement would cause great hardship.
  • Sherman's answer (September 12). Sherman replied that he would not change his mind. He wrote that war is cruelty and cannot be refined, and he said that the surest way to end the suffering was to end the war. He offered to help families with transportation.

The letters hold the argument that would follow Sherman for the rest of his life: that harshness toward a civilian population could be justified by military necessity and a shorter war. Defenders of Sherman have made that argument ever since; critics have answered that the evacuation was needlessly harsh. The record bears out both descriptions of what each side said. The moral argument it leaves for each reader to weigh.

Mid-September: the exodus

A truce was arranged at the village of Rough and Ready, a station on the Macon and Western south of the city. For about ten days, wagons and ambulances carried families out of Atlanta under flags of truce. The commonly cited figure is that about 1,600 civilians were removed. Those who chose to go north went by rail to Chattanooga and then to other places in the Union; those who chose to go south were carried to the truce point and handed to Confederate authorities. They carried what they could, and the city's houses were taken over by the army or left empty.

The number is small beside the city's later history, but it hit a community of families who had known each other for years. In the following weeks the army used the empty houses as quarters, tore down some to use the lumber for defenses and fuel, and built a smaller ring of fortifications around the city center.

October and early November: Atlanta as a fortress

Through October the Union army held Atlanta while Hood's army marched north and tried to cut the railroad that supplied Sherman. Sherman at first chased Hood, then decided against it, and instead proposed a different strategy: to cut loose from his supply line, march through Georgia to the sea, and destroy the state's ability to support the Confederacy. President Lincoln and General Ulysses S. Grant approved the plan after some hesitation.

Before leaving, Sherman wanted to make sure Atlanta could not be used again against him. On November 11, Union forces cut the telegraph wires to the north, ending Sherman's communication with Washington, and began preparations to destroy the city's military and industrial assets.

November 11 to 15: the destruction

Union engineers and soldiers spent several days tearing up the railroad tracks, burning the ties and bending the heated rails around trees, and demolishing the depots, warehouses, shops and factories that could support the Confederacy. Fires spread, and the destruction was not confined to the targets. Large sections of the commercial center and some residences burned. Churches and hospitals were spared after the Episcopal and Catholic bishops asked that they be protected. On November 15 Sherman's army marched out of the city to the southeast, and the March to the Sea began.

How much of Atlanta burned is a matter of long debate: the city did not burn to the ground, as legend says, but it did suffer severe damage, and the rebuilding was a long project. The line between legend and record is the subject of Myths about the burning of Atlanta in 1864.

What came after

The recovery began almost at once. Residents returned in the winter of 1864 and 1865, the railroads were reconstructed, and the capital and the industries that made Atlanta a regional center moved in over the next decade. The state capital arrived in 1868, covered in When the capital moved from Milledgeville to Atlanta in 1868, and the city's emblem of the phoenix, discussed in Resurgens: Atlanta's phoenix motto, its nicknames and the city in a forest, came from the story of burning and rebuilding.

For those who want to see where this happened, the neighborhoods nearest the old railroad yards, including the district now called Downtown and the area south of it around Mechanicsville, hold the traces. Most of the evidence now lives in markers, archives and museum collections rather than surviving buildings; the history museums and the cemetery described in The 1864 siege of Atlanta: four months that burned a railroad city are the best places to start.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic