Blog

The two freeways Atlanta never built: the 1975 eastside revolt

In the 1970s east-side neighbors stopped two planned freeways. What was lost, what replaced them, and why the fight is tied to intown revival and its costs.

Drive east from Downtown on John Lewis Freedom Parkway today and you pass under a canopy of trees, alongside a long linear park, and arrive at a presidential library. It looks like deliberate civic design, a parkway with a park on its flank. It is in fact a leftover from a defeat. The road is what remained after neighbors, lawyers and eventually a governor stopped two freeways that would have sliced through the east side of the city.

The fight is one of the founding stories of Atlanta's intown neighborhoods, and it has two readings. In one, a handful of residents saved a swath of the city from the bulldozers. In the other, the same victory helped start a wave of reinvestment that, decades later, priced many longtime residents out. Both readings have evidence behind them, and neither is complete without the other.

What was planned

In the 1960s the Georgia Department of Transportation began buying land for two freeways on the east side. One was a north-south route that would have run from I-20 through Virginia-Highland to Georgia 400, with an interchange at I-85. The other was an east-west route from the Downtown Connector toward the Stone Mountain area. Together the two were to carry the interstate number I-485.

The project, like many in American cities in that era, rested on the premise that the way to handle growing traffic was to cut new freeways through existing neighborhoods, often neighborhoods that were easier to acquire than downtown office blocks. Georgia's highway department bought property by purchase and by eminent domain. By the time the project was stopped, it had already demolished about 500 homes. At the planned meeting point, on a rise now called Copenhill, a cloverleaf interchange was to go up on the site where a neighborhood had been cleared.

Why the plan looked reasonable then

It is easy to read the freeway plan as plain folly, but the engineers' reasoning had a logic. Atlanta had grown up as a railroad crossroads, and it was becoming a highway crossroads in the same way. Three interstates meet here: I-20 runs east-west, I-75 northwest to southeast and I-85 northeast to southwest. I-75 and I-85 combine through the middle of the city as the Downtown Connector, and I-285, the Perimeter, rings the metro area. Inside that frame, a pair of east-side freeways looked like the missing links: one to carry traffic north and south through the intown neighborhoods to Georgia 400, and one to carry traffic east toward Stone Mountain.

The traffic was real. The Connector alone carries more than 340,000 vehicles a day. And the plan was not a private scheme: it was a state project, funded and run by the state highway department on the assumption that the city's growth would run along highways. The argument that followed was less about whether traffic existed than about what a city should give up to move it.

The revolt

Local protests, lawsuits and the intervention of Governor Jimmy Carter ended the project in the 1970s. The turning point is commonly dated to 1975, when the opposition of east-side neighbors stopped both freeways. The neighborhoods in and beside the freeways' paths were among the city's oldest streetcar suburbs: Inman Park, with its Victorian houses; Little Five Points, on the original streetcar lines; and Virginia-Highland, which lay directly in the path of the north-south route. The story of those streetcar neighborhoods is in The streetcar suburbs of the 1890s: a map of Atlanta's eastside neighborhoods.

The neighbors' victory was a rare one at the time. Highway fights in the era were being lost in cities across the country. What was unusual in Atlanta was the combination of an organized residential base, legal action and a governor willing to side with the opponents.

The empty land

Stopping a freeway did not give the land back. The state had already acquired a corridor, and it sat empty, vacant and overgrown with kudzu for more than twenty years. A neighborhood had been cleared and nothing replaced it.

Two pieces of the answer came later. The Carter Center and the Jimmy Carter Library and Museum now stand on the former Copenhill site. And after Atlanta was selected in 1990 to host the 1996 Olympics, Mayor Maynard Jackson brokered a solution for the rest. The parkway was completed to Ponce de Leon Avenue and Moreland Avenue, and the land to the east was converted into a linear park. Freedom Park was dedicated on September 19, 2000. In 2018 the road was renamed John Lewis Freedom Parkway, in honor of the congressman and civil rights leader.

So the shape of the story is a long delay. A freeway was proposed in the 1960s and defeated in the 1970s, the compromise was settled around 1990, and the park was dedicated in 2000. A road, a park and a library on the same corridor are the product of three decades of argument. The mayor who brokered the compromise is also the subject of The Maynard H. Jackson Jr. terminal and the mayor who rebuilt the airport.

The debate over what followed

Here the account divides. Descriptions of Atlanta's history link the revolt to the start of the "Intown" revival: once the neighborhoods were no longer threatened by a freeway, people with means began buying and restoring houses there. Others tell the same events as the beginning of displacement.

The case that the victory was good rests on what it protected: a set of historic neighborhoods with irreplaceable houses and streets, a park network and the character of the east side. Supporters of the opposition argue that freeways built through such neighborhoods in other cities destroyed them, and that Atlanta's intown neighborhoods are healthier because they were spared.

The case for a more mixed reading points to who benefited. Neighborhoods that were once affordable and have since become expensive are the same ones that fought off the road. A reinvestment wave brings new residents, new businesses and rising rents, and the people who owned or rented in the 1970s do not always stay. Gentrification in Atlanta: a timeline from the freeway fight to the Beltline follows that process across the city.

It would be a mistake to treat the revolt as the sole cause of any of this. Atlanta's intown change had many causes, including the city's economy and its job centers Downtown and in Midtown. What the freeway fight did was remove one threat and leave the neighborhoods to the market.

What the cancellation cost, and what it saved

Put numbers where they exist. The state had demolished about 500 homes before the work stopped, the clearest measure of the damage done even by an unfinished project. The kudzu years, when a cleared corridor sat empty for more than twenty, are the second cost: a wound in the city's fabric that took until 2000, when Freedom Park was dedicated, to heal over.

What it saved is harder to count, because it is the thing that did not happen. The east-side streets that stayed intact, such as the houses of Inman Park and Virginia-Highland, are the counterfactual. A reader can compare them in the mind with the neighborhoods that were cut through elsewhere, the Downtown Connector itself being built through the center of the city.

The comparison is not tidy. Roads that were built are not all harmful, and roads that were stopped are not all benign. But the fight over these two freeways is the best-known case in Atlanta of neighbors, lawyers and a governor deciding that a plan was wrong, and of a city living with the consequences for fifty years.

What the city has instead

The land that became Freedom Park is now a green corridor running east from the Old Fourth Ward side toward the Carter Center. It sits close to the BeltLine's Eastside Trail, the subject of The Eastside Trail: a walk along the Beltline from Piedmont Park to Reynoldstown, and a reader can walk or bike the park to reach it.

The Downtown Connector, by contrast, is the road Atlanta did build: the I-75/85 stretch through the middle of the city carries more than 340,000 vehicles a day. The two canceled freeways would have been parts of the same system. The contrast makes a reader ask what a city looks like when it builds one set of roads and not another, and the east side of Atlanta is the experiment.

How to see it

A short tour is possible without a car.

  1. Start at the Carter Center and Library, on the former Copenhill site, and look at the grade of the land. The hill is the cloverleaf's old footprint.
  2. Walk or ride the Freedom Park trail west toward the Old Fourth Ward, and notice how the park corridor runs where the road would have gone.
  3. Cross to the neighborhoods the freeway would have cut: Inman Park to the south and Virginia-Highland to the north, and note how the streets of single-family houses remain intact.
  4. Continue toward the BeltLine's Eastside Trail, which runs close to the park's western end.

Anyone who wants a driver's view of the road network that does exist can read Driving in Atlanta: the interstates, the Connector and the Perimeter.

It is also worth remembering how recent all of this is. Freedom Park was dedicated on September 19, 2000, and the parkway took its present name in 2018, so the people who fought the freeways in the 1970s, and the people who now jog the park, overlap in a single generation or two. That is part of why the argument still feels live on the east side: the neighbors who won in 1975 and the neighbors who arrived afterward are still talking to one another, and not always about the same thing.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic