Blog
Trees and development: the debate over Atlanta's tree ordinance
What builders, tree advocates and the council each argued over Atlanta's rewritten tree ordinance, and what the June 2025 vote did and did not settle.
On Monday, June 16, 2025, the Atlanta City Council voted without dissent to approve a rewrite of the city's tree protection ordinance. The vote was unanimous, but almost nobody in the room called the outcome a clean win. Builders said they had given ground. Tree advocates said they had not been given enough. Council members who voted yes said, in the same breath, that they would be back for more. The dispute is a good case study in the oldest argument in a growing city: how much of the green stuff you give up in exchange for more places to live and work.
The setup: a 25-year-old rule and a shrinking canopy
The ordinance being replaced had been in force for about a quarter century. Earlier attempts to update it had failed. Trees Atlanta, the nonprofit that plants and cares for trees in the city, counts the 2025 push as the third serious attempt, after efforts in 2014 and 2018 that collapsed amid long delays. A first phase of changes passed in 2023.
Meanwhile the canopy was shrinking. Atlanta's cover was 47.9 percent in 2008 and 46.5 percent in a 2018 Georgia Tech analysis, a decline of about a point and a half in a decade. The city's goal is 50 percent. Advocates said the real figure had fallen further since and predicted that a newer assessment would come in below 45 percent. The background on those numbers and the basic mechanics of the ordinance are in The city in a forest: Atlanta's tree canopy and the ordinance that protects it.
The city is also a growing one, and new construction on vacant and wooded lots is where the two interests meet. That is the tension the ordinance sits on top of.
What the ordinance does
At its core, the tree ordinance does three things. It requires a permit for removing protected trees, which the Office of Buildings handles. It charges "recompense," a fee set per diameter inch of the tree removed, that goes into the Tree Trust Fund, a dedicated account separate from the city's general fund that pays for planting and related work and is overseen by the Tree Conservation Commission. And it sets penalties for removing trees illegally.
Everyone in the 2025 debate agreed on that structure. The fight was about the numbers and the standards.
The builders' case
The development industry, represented in the debate by groups such as the Council for Quality Growth, argued from three points:
- Cost and predictability. A recompense fee is a cost of doing business, and builders asked for a fee structure they could price into a project in advance. Caps on per-acre fees, in their view, make costs predictable.
- Housing goals. Preservation standards that require a developer to keep a share of existing trees on a site can reduce the number of homes that fit on it. Builders argued that such standards would hamper development and the city's affordable housing goals.
- Testing. Builders and some city officials said the preservation standards needed more testing and should be aligned with a rewrite of the zoning code, rather than adopted on a separate track.
The Council for Quality Growth backed the final ordinance as a compromise and said that everyone still had items on the table.
The advocates' case
Trees Atlanta and other tree advocates, together with some council members, argued the opposite on each point:
- Price versus replacement. They said the recompense rate, even after it was raised, was below the real cost of replacing a mature tree, which takes decades to grow. A fee cheaper than the value lost is, in their view, a subsidy to clearing.
- Caps that invite clear-cutting. A cap on per-acre fees means a developer who removes more trees pays no more, and so has no incentive to save any. One tree commission member and environmental lawyer said the ordinance again enabled developers to clear-cut.
- Standards, not just fees. Advocates wanted tree preservation and density standards, which require that trees be kept or planted, written into the ordinance. They called the call for more testing a delay tactic, since delay lets tree loss continue.
- Other protections. They also wanted stream and wetland buffers protected, an affordable-housing discount proportional to the share of affordable units, and a cap on how much of the Tree Trust Fund could be spent on things other than planting.
What the council and mayor did
The Community Development and Human Services Committee had advanced a substitute version on June 10, 2025, by a vote of four in favor, one against and one abstaining. That version left out the preservation standards builders had objected to, which the city's planning commissioner said needed to be held back for testing alongside the zoning code update. It restored discounts for affordable housing.
When the full council voted on June 16, the result was unanimous. The mayor supported it. But some council members said they would keep pushing for stronger protections, and one said he planned legislation to track progress on the preservation standard.
What the ordinance now says
The version approved on June 16, 2025, took effect on January 1, 2026, and includes:
- A tree removal fee of $140 per diameter inch of trunk, indexed to metro Atlanta inflation from January 1, 2027.
- Caps on per-acre removal fees of $12,500 to $35,000, depending on zoning, available only to new subdivisions, new lots of record and vacant lots that preserve a set percentage of existing trees.
- Minimum tree-density requirements for planting on single-family lots.
- A maximum penalty of $200,000 per acre where the number of illegally removed trees cannot be determined, and a $500 fine for a first single illegal removal, $1,000 for later ones, plus replacement payments.
- Reduced recompense fees for affordable housing units.
- A $400,000 allocation from the Tree Trust Fund to help low-income senior homeowners trim or remove hazardous trees.
- A requirement that tree service companies register with the city.
The caps were the last item to be settled. They had been left out of an early draft, and builders objected; they were restored in the final version, and advocates objected in turn, arguing that caps do not do enough to discourage clear-cutting.
A worked example: what the fee means
A hypothetical shows how the numbers play out. These are illustrations of the arithmetic, not records of any real project.
A single homeowner. Say a homeowner needs to remove one protected oak with a trunk diameter of 24 inches. At $140 per diameter inch, the recompense is 24 x $140 = $3,360. Whether a hazardous tree qualifies for any reduction is a question for the city's permit staff.
A small builder. Say a builder clears ten protected trees averaging 18 inches across. That is 180 inches, and 180 x $140 = $25,200.
A subdivision on an acre of woods. Say a developer clears an acre that holds 60 protected trees averaging 12 inches, a total of 720 inches. The uncapped fee would be 720 x $140 = $100,800. If the site qualifies for the cap, which is $12,500 to $35,000 per acre depending on zoning, the developer pays no more than the cap, so at the top of the range, $35,000. The cap would cut the bill by about $65,800 on that acre.
That last example is the crux of the dispute. The cap makes costs predictable for a builder, and it also means that, past a point, clearing more trees on the same acre costs nothing extra. To qualify, a site has to preserve a set percentage of its existing trees, the condition the council attached to the cap. How much protection that condition buys depends on the percentage, and on enforcement.
What is not in dispute
It is worth noticing how much both sides agree on. Both accept that the city's canopy matters, that the goal of 50 percent is worth pursuing and that trees removed should be paid for. They agree that the old ordinance needed updating, and that illegal removal should be penalized more heavily than it was. They agree that homeowners with hazardous trees should be able to get help, which is why the senior assistance fund, raised to $400,000, was approved in committee without a dissenting vote. The argument is over the exchange rate: how many dollars, and what kind of rules, balance a tree against a building.
Weighing the two sides
Neither side's argument is silly, and the disagreement is mostly about what to weigh. The builders' strongest point is that a city with a housing shortage cannot make every lot a preserve, and that a fee schedule people can predict gets more projects built than an uncertain one. The advocates' strongest point is that a tree's value includes shade, stormwater control and cooling, none of which a developer pays for, and that a canopy lost to a construction site does not come back in a lifetime.
Both sides concede something else: the real test is what happens next. The preservation standards were postponed, not killed, and the city said it would revisit them with the zoning code update. Whether the 2025 rewrite slows the decline of the canopy will be answered by the next canopy measurement, not by the vote. Until then the argument stays live in the city's planning process; see How to get a building permit in Atlanta for how tree review fits into a project, Department of City Planning and building permits for the department that administers it and Atlanta City Council for the body that wrote it.
What residents can do
Residents who care about a specific tree or site have a few channels. Suspected illegal cutting can be reported through ATL311. Neighborhood groups and the nonprofit tree organizations track permit applications. And the City Council and its committees take public comment on ordinances, which is how the substitute version of June 2025 was shaped.