Blog

Welcoming city but not sanctuary city, and what Atlanta's 2017 position means

The January 2017 welcoming-city declaration, the city closing its detention center to ICE detainees, and the stated line between welcoming and sanctuary.

Two phrases do most of the shouting in American arguments over how cities handle immigration: "welcoming city" and "sanctuary city." They sound like cousins, and in public debate they are often treated as twins. Atlanta's own position, set out in early 2017, was deliberately one and not the other. The city declared itself welcoming, closed its detention center to federal immigration detainees, and said that did not make it a sanctuary city. What each phrase means, what Atlanta did and what supporters and critics make of it is the subject here, and the account sticks to the public record and takes no side.

The two phrases

Neither phrase has a single legal definition, which is a large part of why the fight is so hard to settle.

"Welcoming city" is a label cities use for policies and attitudes meant to integrate immigrants: language access in city services, outreach to immigrant communities, support for newcomers' businesses and schools, and statements that residents are welcome regardless of status. A welcoming declaration is chiefly a statement of values and a commitment to inclusion.

"Sanctuary city" is a looser label, used in political debate for local governments that limit how much their own resources go toward helping federal immigration enforcement. What a "sanctuary" policy includes varies a great deal from place to place: limits on police inquiries about immigration status, refusal to hold people in jail past their release date solely at a federal agency's request, restrictions on sharing information, and other measures. Because supporters, critics and officials all use the term differently, a city that says it is not a sanctuary city may still have some of these policies, and a city critics call a sanctuary may reject the label.

That ambiguity is the backdrop to Atlanta's wording. When the city drew a line between welcoming and sanctuary, it was drawing a line between a set of values and services and a set of limits on cooperation with federal enforcement.

What Atlanta did in 2017

In January 2017 Atlanta's city government issued a welcoming-city declaration. In the same period the city announced that it would stop holding federal immigration detainees in its detention center. A city statement, quoted in reference sources, describes the decision to close the detention center to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, detainees. The city's position, as stated at the time, was that welcoming immigrants and refusing to use city jail space for federal immigration detention were not the same as declaring the city a sanctuary.

Several details matter in reading that decision.

  • Whose jail? The city runs its own detention center, operated by the Atlanta Department of Corrections. The Fulton County Jail, by contrast, is run by the county sheriff. The 2017 decision concerned the city's facility. It did not govern the county jail, a separate institution under a separately elected sheriff; see The Fulton County Sheriff and the county jail, and what the office does.
  • What it changed. The city's detention center would no longer hold people on behalf of ICE.
  • What it did not do. It did not declare that the city would shield anyone from federal law, and it did not claim to be a sanctuary jurisdiction.

The point of the distinction, as the city framed it, was to say what Atlanta would do (welcome newcomers, decline to use its facility for federal immigration detention) and what it did not claim to do. Whether the line means much is something people disagree about.

What supporters of the approach say

Supporters of Atlanta's 2017 position make several arguments.

  • Trust in policing. Police need residents to report crimes and cooperate as witnesses. If immigrants fear that any contact with local government could end in deportation, they may stay away, which can make everyone less safe.
  • Resources. Immigration enforcement is a federal responsibility, and a city jail's space and staff are limited. Declining to hold federal detainees keeps the facility focused on city business.
  • Economic and civic participation. Immigrants are part of the city's workforce, schools, congregations and neighborhoods, and a welcoming stance reflects that. The metro's immigrant communities, including the Buford Highway corridor and parts of Gwinnett and DeKalb, are described in Immigrant Atlanta: Gwinnett, DeKalb and the Buford Highway belt.
  • Clarity. Drawing the line between welcoming and sanctuary lets the city say what it is doing without wading into the larger legal fight.

What critics say

Critics raise different concerns, and they come from more than one direction.

  • From those who favor stricter enforcement: that declining to hold ICE detainees reduces cooperation with federal law enforcement, that it can allow people who are in the country unlawfully and wanted by federal authorities to be released, and that local governments should assist federal enforcement as the law allows.
  • From those who favor stronger protections: that distinguishing welcoming from sanctuary is too cautious, and that a city that wants to protect immigrants should go further, for instance by limiting more kinds of cooperation or by extending services more broadly.
  • On the legal and political risk: that local policies in this area can draw responses from state and federal governments, including threats to funding or legislation restricting local policies. How such disputes play out depends on state and federal law, which has changed over time and is for lawyers to read, not for a summary like this one.

These are summaries of arguments, not findings. The record of what the city did in 2017 is public; the debate over whether it was right is a political one.

How this fits in Atlanta's governance

The policies at issue sit across several layers. The city sets the rules for its own police department and its own detention facility. The county sheriff, elected separately, runs the county jail and makes the decisions about it. The state legislature can and does pass laws about what local governments may do on immigration. The federal government enforces immigration law and decides which detainees it holds and where. A resident trying to understand a specific case, such as whether a particular person was transferred to federal custody, needs to find out which of those bodies was involved.

For the city's police department, the practical guidance for residents is in How to reach police, fire and emergency help in Atlanta, and the department itself is profiled in Atlanta Police Department. Civilian oversight of police and corrections officers is the subject of Who watches the police: the Atlanta Citizen Review Board.

Read the text, not the label

Because the language here is contested, the useful move is to go to the primary documents: the text of the city's declaration, the city's own statements and any ordinance or executive order that applies. News coverage and advocacy groups on every side characterize these in their own terms. A reader who wants to know exactly what the city did should look for the text of the policy, not a label.

What a resident should know

  • Emergencies: 911 is for emergencies regardless of anyone's status.
  • City services: the city's non-emergency service line, 311, and its departments serve residents of the city.
  • Legal questions about immigration status: these belong to immigration lawyers and accredited representatives, and to the federal agencies that handle immigration. The city is not the place for legal advice on a case.
  • Where the jail is county-run: the county's policies, not the city's, govern.

The broader story of immigrant communities in the metro region, including how they have redrawn the map of the area, is in Immigrant Atlanta: Gwinnett, DeKalb and the Buford Highway belt. What is described here is the city's stated position in 2017, and nothing in it speaks to any change since.

Reading the 2017 moment in context

The early months of 2017 were a time of intense national argument over immigration enforcement, and many cities announced positions. Atlanta's was one of many, and its choice of words, welcoming and not sanctuary, separates two things opponents and supporters often lump together. The separation had a practical logic: a city can decide how it uses its own jail and its own programs, while the legal question of what it may refuse to do in cooperation with federal agencies is a different matter, argued in the courts and the legislatures.

It is worth remembering what a declaration does and doesn't do. It is a statement of policy intent. It can guide departments, shape budgets and tell residents how the city sees them. It does not change a statute. If a state law applies to local governments, it applies whatever a city declares, and where state and federal law set requirements, those requirements stand. How much a local declaration changes what happens on the ground depends on how it is carried out, by police, by the jail, by the departments that serve residents.

A short list of questions for any local policy

In Atlanta or anywhere else, a reader trying to understand a local policy on immigration can ask a few questions that cut through labels.

  1. Which facility or agency does it cover? A city jail, a county jail and a state prison are three different institutions.
  2. What does it require or forbid? Look for the verbs: hold, release, share, inquire, notify.
  3. Who decides? An ordinance, an executive order and a department policy are different instruments.
  4. When was it adopted, and has it changed? Policies in this area have shifted over time.
  5. What does state and federal law say? Local policy operates inside those limits.

Put those questions to Atlanta's 2017 position and some points come out clearly while others are left to the text of the documents: the facility was the city's detention center, the action was a decision not to hold ICE detainees there, the instrument was a city statement and decision, and the label the city chose for itself was welcoming, not sanctuary.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic