Blog

Why Emory and Cumberland never got a train

MARTA's rail map misses two of the metro's big destinations. The votes behind the map, a 2011 Brookings ranking and the Emory line still under discussion.

Ask a longtime Atlantan why the train doesn't go to Emory University or to Cumberland and you'll get a shrug first and then a story about a vote. Both places rank among the biggest concentrations of jobs, students and visitors in the metro area. Neither has a MARTA rail station. This is why, as far as the public history shows, and what has been proposed since.

Two destinations, two different problems

Emory University and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention sit in the northeast, in the Druid Hills area of DeKalb County, a neighborhood described in Druid Hills and Druid Hills: a city neighborhood and a county census place. The CDC campus was annexed into the City of Atlanta effective January 1, 2018, and the two institutions are neighbors, as Emory and the CDC: neighbors on the DeKalb side describes. Emory has been studied for rail for years: the area is thick with employees, students and patients.

Cumberland is another matter. It is in Cobb County, northwest of the city, home to the stadium where the Braves play, Truist Park, which opened in 2017, and the mixed-use district around it. Its trouble is less density than jurisdiction: Cobb County is outside MARTA's rail network because of a vote taken in the 1960s.

The two cases are related but distinct. One is a gap inside the system's own counties; the other is a gap made by a county that never joined.

The votes

MARTA's early history is a history of referendums, and the results explain the map. In 1965 four of the five metro counties, Clayton, DeKalb, Fulton and Gwinnett, along with the City of Atlanta, approved participating in the new transit authority. The referendum failed in Cobb County. In 1968 a referendum to fund the system failed. In 1971 Fulton and DeKalb passed a one percent sales tax to pay for it, while Clayton and Gwinnett overwhelmingly rejected it. Rail construction began in 1975, and service started in June 1979. How MARTA rail came to Atlanta, 1975 to 1988 tells the story.

The consequence was that rail was built only in the counties that had paid for it, Fulton and DeKalb. Cobb voters didn't join in 1965, so there was no MARTA tax and no rail there. Gwinnett voters rejected the tax in 1971, and the same holds there. A visitor can see the result on the map, which stops at the county lines.

That didn't mean no transit at all. MARTA operates a bus route that serves the Cumberland Boulevard Transfer Center in Cobb County, which lies outside MARTA's main service area, and Cobb's own system, CobbLinc, runs buses in the county. Gwinnett has its own transit system. But a bus is not a train, and the gap in rail has been a long-standing complaint.

The 2011 ranking

In 2011 the Brookings Institution published a study of transit access in the country's 100 largest metro areas, measuring how many jobs people could reach by transit. In that ranking Atlanta came in 91st out of 100. The figure gets cited whenever the region's weakness in transit comes up, and it helps to know what it does and doesn't say. It measures access to jobs for the metro area as a whole, not the quality of MARTA within its own service area. A rail line can't take someone to a job it doesn't reach, and that is the shape of the problem.

The ranking is more than a decade old, and transit has changed since: the 2016 More MARTA vote, the BeltLine and, in 2026, the start of construction of the first arterial rapid transit corridor. But the study caught something real, and it still shapes how people talk about the region.

The Emory line

The idea of a rail line to Emory is long-standing and has gone by many names. As of October 2011, planners were examining rapid transit options for the Clifton Corridor, running from Lindbergh Center along a freight rail corridor to Emory University and the CDC, and possibly continuing to Avondale station. Light rail was selected as the preferred option. An earlier proposal, the Tucker-North DeKalb Line, would have served Emory and North Druid Hills. Today a light rail line from Avondale to Lindbergh by way of Emory and the CDC is still described as under consideration.

The project hasn't been built. The reasons are the usual ones for transit megaprojects: money, competing priorities and the difficulty of fitting rail into an established neighborhood. In March 2023 MARTA scaled back its 2028 priorities to six transit lines and three station projects, a sign of how limited funds force choices among many proposals. Whether the Emory line is among the lines that proceed is a question for MARTA's own plans, and a reader who wants the current status should consult them.

What fills the gap: the Cliff

Where MARTA doesn't go, Emory runs its own buses. The Cliff shuttle system has more than 50 buses and 21 routes and carries about 200,000 rides a month. It serves the campus and connects it with nearby places, and it is, in effect, a private transit system inside the metro area's public one. That a university has built its own network of that size is a measure of the need, and of how much the gap has cost.

For Cumberland, the equivalents are county and regional bus services, plus the commuter buses of the regional ATL Xpress system, which runs buses between the suburbs and the center.

The case for building, and the case for caution

The arguments on each side are straightforward.

For rail to Emory and to the northwest. These are major destinations, and a train would offer a reliable alternative to crowded highways. Students, employees and patients would gain access to jobs and care without a car. The 2011 ranking shows how few jobs Atlantans can reach by transit, and each major destination added to the rail network would raise it.

For caution. Rail is expensive to build, and its cost per mile in a built-up area can run very high. The history of MARTA's referendums shows that voters in some counties have repeatedly declined to pay for it. A bus rapid transit corridor may deliver much of the benefit for far less money, and the 2026 project on the southside, described in The Cleveland-Metropolitan arterial rapid transit line begins construction, is an example of that approach.

Both sets of arguments are real, and the choice among them belongs to the agency, the city and the voters in the counties concerned.

A timeline of the decisions

Year Decision
1965 Four of five metro counties and the City of Atlanta approve joining; Cobb votes no
1968 A referendum to fund MARTA fails
1971 Fulton and DeKalb pass a 1 percent sales tax; Clayton and Gwinnett reject it
1975 Rail construction begins
1979 Rail service opens in June
2007 MARTA seeks a 15-year extension of its tax; Atlanta's council approves 12 to 1
2011 Planners select light rail as the preferred option for the Clifton Corridor; Brookings ranks Atlanta 91st of 100 for transit access to jobs
2016 Atlanta voters approve the More MARTA half-cent tax
2020 The four jurisdictions approve keeping the full 1 percent through 2057
2023 MARTA scales back its 2028 priorities to six lines and three station projects

The table shows how slowly a transit map changes. Two of the decisions that shaped today's map, in 1965 and 1971, were made by voters more than half a century ago. The decisions since have mostly been about keeping and extending what exists. The 2020 vote to keep the full one percent through 2057 secured the system's money for decades, which is a different thing from building a new line to a new place.

Cobb, Gwinnett and the question of regional transit

The deeper issue is that the metro area has never had one transit system. MARTA serves the core. Cobb has its own bus system, Gwinnett has its own, and ATL Xpress runs regional commuter buses. The result is a patchwork, and a rider crossing from one county to the next may meet a different fare, a different schedule and a different system.

The mayor's stated goal of expanding MARTA into a regional system, announced as a priority for his second term, answers that patchwork. Whether it can succeed depends on what counties and voters outside the current network want, and history suggests the question will be settled at the ballot box and not in a planning office. The Atlanta Regional Commission and the 11-county map looks at the regional planning body that tries to coordinate across county lines.

What it means for a rider today

For someone trying to reach Emory without a car, the practical answer is a combination: MARTA rail to a station near the campus, such as Lindbergh Center or another station in the Midtown corridor, then a bus, or the Cliff shuttle, which MARTA riders and others use. Do the planning with MARTA's trip planner. For Cumberland, a rider needs a bus to the Cumberland Boulevard Transfer Center. Getting around Atlanta without a car covers the options.

The larger lesson is about how a map gets made. MARTA's rail lines run where voters approved a tax in 1971 and where construction went in the 1970s and 1980s, and the places not served then have been waiting since. The rail map is, in a real sense, the map of a set of votes.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic