Blog

The Atlanta Six and the 1930 insurrection arrests

Six Communist organizers arrested in spring 1930 under a statute that carried the death penalty, and the free-speech case it set up in the Herndon trial.

Spring of 1930 found the Great Depression shutting factories and putting jobless men on the streets, and Atlanta police raided two meetings sponsored by the Communist Party and hauled in six organizers. The charge was not trespass or disorderly conduct. It was "attempting to incite insurrection," under an old Georgia statute that carried the death penalty. The six, known afterward as the Atlanta Six, never went to trial on that charge, yet their case set the stage for one of the most important free-speech decisions of the 1930s. Here is who they were, what the law said, and how the case fed into the better-known trial of Angelo Herndon.

Atlanta in 1930

The city was already the commercial center of the Southeast, with a railroad economy, a growing Black middle class around Auburn Avenue and a deeply segregated social order. Cotton mills across the region employed white workers under hard conditions, and unions were weak in Georgia. The stock-market crash of 1929 had hit the region's wage-earners, and by 1930 unemployment was rising in the city. Radical organizers, including members of the Communist Party of the United States, tried to organize both Black and white workers, and the party's insistence on interracial organizing was exactly what Georgia authorities found threatening. The background of the era in the city is in How Atlanta outgrew Savannah by 1880 and the long history of racial division in The 1906 Atlanta race riot.

The party's Atlanta efforts included mass meetings, leaflets and demonstrations on unemployment relief. The national party's legal arm, the International Labor Defense, took on defendants who were prosecuted for their politics.

The arrests

Between March and May of 1930, Atlanta police arrested six people in two raids on Communist-sponsored labor meetings. The historical record names them as Morris H. Powers, Joseph Carr, Mary Dalton, Ann Burlak, Herbert Newton and Henry Storey. They were Black and white, women and men, a mix that was deliberate on the party's part and provocative to the city's authorities. One of them, Ann Burlak, had been sent to Atlanta by the National Textile Workers Union to organize mill workers into multiracial unions. She sat in jail for about six weeks before being released on bail, and afterward toured the country raising money for the defense.

The six were charged with "attempting to incite insurrection." The statute had been used rarely, and its roots lay in the early nineteenth century, when slaveholders passed laws to deter slave rebellions. It was revised in the late 1860s to apply to insurrection more generally, then largely forgotten, until prosecutors in the 1930s found it useful against radicals. A conviction could mean death.

The International Labor Defense represented the six, and its lawyers used delay as a tool. They filed motions, challenged the indictments and pushed back trial dates. The delay served the defense in two ways. It kept the six out of a courtroom where an all-white jury in 1930s Atlanta would have been likely to convict, and it let the case become a national cause. Money raised through speaking tours paid for the bail and the legal work.

By 1932 the case was still unresolved. That year, prosecutors set the Atlanta Six charges aside, in effect tabling them, to make way for the prosecution of a different organizer whom Atlanta officials considered more dangerous: Angelo Herndon. The record shows that the ILD kept making bond payments for years, and that the charges against Burlak and the others were formally dropped in 1939, after the Supreme Court had struck down the statute.

The Herndon case

Angelo Herndon was a young Black Communist organizer. On June 30, 1932, nearly a thousand unemployed workers, Black and white, gathered at a government courthouse in Atlanta to demand relief. On July 11, 1932, two Atlanta detectives arrested him at the Post Office. Police searched his hotel room and found Communist Party literature. He was held for nearly six months, and the ILD paid $7,000 bail. On January 18, 1933, an all-white jury convicted him of attempting to incite insurrection, and he was sentenced to 18 to 20 years on the chain gang.

His case went through the courts for years. In December 1935 a state appeals court overturned the conviction and he was released on bail. The Georgia Supreme Court later upheld the original conviction, and in 1937 the case reached the United States Supreme Court. On April 26, 1937, in Herndon v. Lowry, the Court ruled 5 to 4 that the statute, as applied, violated the First Amendment rights of free speech and assembly. Justice Owen J. Roberts, writing for the majority, described the law as a dragnet that could enmesh anyone advocating political change. The ruling ended the use of the statute against political organizers, and the remaining charges against the Atlanta Six were dropped.

A timeline

  • Spring 1930: Six organizers are arrested in two raids and charged with attempting to incite insurrection.
  • 1930 to 1932: The defense delays the trial; the six are out on bail and become a national cause.
  • June 30, 1932: Nearly 1,000 unemployed workers, Black and white, demonstrate in Atlanta.
  • July 11, 1932: Angelo Herndon is arrested.
  • 1932: Prosecutors table the Atlanta Six charges.
  • January 18, 1933: Herndon is convicted and sentenced to 18 to 20 years.
  • December 1935: A state appeals court overturns the conviction; the Georgia Supreme Court later upholds it again.
  • April 26, 1937: The U.S. Supreme Court, 5 to 4, strikes down the statute as applied.
  • 1939: Remaining charges against the Atlanta Six and other defendants are dropped, and the International Labor Defense's regular bond payments end.

Why the statute mattered

The Court's reasoning in the Herndon case turned on a particular problem. The Georgia law made it a capital crime to attempt to incite insurrection, but the definition was so broad that it did not require a connection to any immediate violence. A person who held a meeting or handed out a pamphlet could be prosecuted on the theory that, at some point, the words might lead to unrest. The Court held that this left the boundary of the crime too vague for a person to know in advance what speech was forbidden, and that it punished advocacy as such. That reasoning is a thread in later First Amendment law about the difference between abstract advocacy and incitement.

For readers in Atlanta the case also has a local meaning. It was an episode in the city's long argument over who gets to speak in public and under what conditions. The courts that handled the case belong to the system explained in Municipal, magistrate, superior and federal: how the courts around Atlanta fit together, and today's courthouse district, where the 1932 demonstration drew its crowd, is the subject of The Fulton County courthouse complex: a walk down Pryor Street.

What the 1937 decision means in plain terms

Lawyers call the central problem vagueness. A criminal law has to tell a person what is forbidden, so that no one has to guess whether a meeting, a speech or a pamphlet crosses the line. The insurrection statute, as the prosecution used it, did not say how close to actual violence speech had to be, and it did not require any plan for a specific uprising. That left the decision to the judgment of the police and a jury, in a place where the police and the jury were both likely to be hostile to the speakers. The Court's description of the law as a dragnet reflects that worry.

The ruling also shows how a local prosecution can become a national precedent. The defendant was one young man in Atlanta; the principle that governments may not punish advocacy of political change without a closer link to violence applies everywhere. In that sense the Atlanta Six and Herndon cases are part of the history of rights every American holds, and they belong to Atlanta's civic history too.

What historians weigh

Several questions remain open for historians, and a careful reader can hold them side by side.

  • Was the prosecution about violence or politics? The defense argued that the six were arrested for their beliefs and their interracial organizing. The prosecution argued that the party's goal was revolution and that the statute protected public order. The Supreme Court's later ruling sided with the defense on the First Amendment question.
  • How much did race drive the case? Georgia authorities' alarm was at least partly about Black and white workers organizing together. The racial order of the state, with its segregation and its history of racial violence, shaped what the police and the courts saw as dangerous.
  • What did the delay accomplish? By keeping the case alive for years, the ILD built a national campaign. The party's opponents saw a campaign built around its own cause; its defenders answered that the defendants had no other advocates.

Following the paper trail

Anyone who wants to read the legal outcome will find the 1937 decision as a published United States Supreme Court opinion, available on the court's own site and in law libraries. The history of Georgia's court system and its records is handled through Fulton County Superior Court. The case's wider setting in the city's history, including the city's other upheavals in the first half of the twentieth century, is part of The Leo Frank case, 1913 to 1915 and The Great Atlanta Fire of May 21, 1917. The Depression's local effects are explored in Atlanta in World War II: factories, bases and a changed city, which picks up the story when the economy recovered.

The six, briefly

The historical record names the six as Morris H. Powers, Joseph Carr, Mary Dalton, Ann Burlak, Herbert Newton and Henry Storey. Burlak is the best documented: she was an organizer for the National Textile Workers Union who spent about six weeks in jail and then toured the country raising money for the defense. The group mixed women and men, Black and white, which is what made the party's interracial organizing so alarming to Georgia authorities. For the six, the practical result was years of living under a capital charge that was never tried, with bail posted by a legal-defense organization.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic